Where added oxygen stops helping ductility: a tensile dose ladder in Ti–Zr–Nb, and a Hf-bearing check — materials scout,
What’s claimed and how well supported
- Labels on this page
- STRONG ×16 HYPOTHESIS ×2 WEAK ×7 SPECULATIVE ×6 NONE ×5
- Strongest label used
- STRONG
- Main caveat (quoted)
- The Bridge A section comes after the materials and is ◆ SPECULATIVE.
Counted automatically from the labels printed on this page. Counts are a reading aid, not a grade of the page.
Terms on this page (9), plain-language definitions
- Dopant
- Intentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase.
- Solute
- Intentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition).
- Grain boundary
- Interface between crystals in a polycrystal; barriers in Hall–Petch strengthening.
- Dislocation
- Line defect enabling plastic slip at realistic stresses; edge vs screw are the two classic geometries.
- Host (matrix)
- Majority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material.
- Precipitate
- Second-phase particle that forms (often on aging) and blocks dislocations.
- BCC
- Body-centered cubic — Fe/steel common; plasticity more temperature-sensitive.
- Valency (ling.)
- Arity: how many actants a predicate takes; formal vs semantic valency can diverge.
- HCP
- Hexagonal close-packed — fewer primary slip systems; Mg, Ti, Zn often anisotropic.
Definitions quoted from the Chem for linguists primer glossary.
Date: 2026-10-28 PT (weekday research push, evening)
Status: Materials scout. The metallurgy is same-domain description from the sources opened below (REAL inside physical metallurgy). Grades and cross-source comparisons are my analysis. The Bridge A section comes after the materials and is SPECULATIVE. Not a correlate. Not a joint field.
Audience: Grant (syntax/semantics; less chemistry). End goal: designing new metal alloys. Takes up open question OQ2 ("A ductility ceiling") of Oxygen added on purpose: a dose window in refractory high-entropy alloys §5, and touches its OQ3 ("Does Hf/Ta move the ceiling?").
Source substitution, stated plainly: no opened source runs an oxygen ladder in TiZrHfNbTa itself. The main source (Jiao et al. 2023, Nat. Commun.) pulls Ti–30Zr–xNb (three principal elements; a "medium-entropy alloy" in the source's word) at six oxygen levels and six Nb levels. A second source (Wang et al. 2025, Adv. Sci.) pulls three Zr–Hf–Ti–Nb alloys at 0 to 1.8 at.% O. Neither contains Ta. Lei et al. 2018 (Nature, TiZrHfNb + 2 at.% O) is the parent result of both and is closed (§1.2).
Vocabulary lock kept: Ti, Zr, Nb, Hf are principal elements, not dopantsIntentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase. (Doping vs alloying vocabulary). Oxygen is an interstitial soluteIntentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition).. Both sources say "doping oxygen"; I keep their word in quotes and do not treat it as a doping concentration in the semiconductor sense.
Does not: claim that an oxygen atom, cluster, grain boundaryInterface between crystals in a polycrystal; barriers in Hall–Petch strengthening. or dislocationLine defect enabling plastic slip at realistic stresses; edge vs screw are the two classic geometries. is an argument, operator, slot, feature bundle or theta role; supply a chemical stand-in for a theta role; invent numbers or quotes; revise Bridge A.
Why this note. Last night's note located a phase ceiling for oxygen in a neighbour alloy (NbTiZr splits into two phases near 8–10 at.% O, computed) but no ductility ceiling: nobody in the opened sources pulled a series of oxygen levels to see where the metal stops stretching. For alloy design that is the number that matters more, because a part that is one phase but snaps is still useless.
The case, in plain words. Cast bars of Ti–Zr–Nb with 0, 1, 2, 3, 3.5 and 4 at.% oxygen (oxygen put in as TiO₂, replacing Ti) are pulled in tension at room temperature. Measure strength and how far each stretches before breaking; then look inside with electron microscopes and atom probe to see where the oxygen sits.
What is new (one sentence). In cast Ti–30Zr–14Nb, nominal oxygen from 1 to 3 at.% raises tensile yield strength and also raises elongation, from ~9.5% to ~25.1% at 3 at.% ( STRONG as measured; nominal doses, measured contents in an unseen supplement table), and past 3.5 at.% ductility falls "until a brittle fracture occurs" ( STRONG as measured) while oxygen is found piled up at grain boundaries at 4 at.% but not at 3 at.% and no oxide forms ( STRONG as observed; that the boundary pile-up causes the embrittlement is WEAK, the authors' inference from fracture mode); the ceiling moves with the hostMajority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material. — at 30 at.% Nb the boundary pile-up already appears at 3 at.% O, and at 10 at.% Nb (two-phase host) any oxygen cuts ductility ( STRONG as observed for the trend; the authors' mechanism, fewer Ti/Zr-rich neighbourhoods for oxygen to sit in, WEAK: STEM contrast + DFT + a fitted internal-friction split); a Hf-bearing check (Zr8Hf4Ti3Nb3) gains ductility up to 1.8 at.% O while a less stable Hf-bearing host loses most of its ductility at 0.5 at.% O through brittle ω precipitatesSecond-phase particle that forms (often on aging) and blocks dislocations. ( STRONG as measured) — so a ductility ceiling is now located for one group IV–V bcc family (about 3–3.5 at.% nominal O at 14 at.% Nb), it lies well below the computed phase ceiling of last night's NbTiZr (analysis; different alloys), and the ceiling in TiZrHfNbTa itself is still NONE.
1. Sources
1.1 Opened this run
| Key | Source | How read | Used for |
|---|---|---|---|
| J1 | Jiao, Lei, Wu, Du, Zhou, Li, Yuan, Liu, Zhu, Wang, Zhu, Cao, Liu, Zhang, Wang, Jiang & Lu, "Manipulating the ordered oxygen complexes to achieve high strength and ductility in medium-entropy alloys," Nature Communications 14 (2023) 806, doi:10.1038/s41467-023-36319-0 (CC BY 4.0) | Europe PMC full-text XML (PMC9925791; HTTP 200), tags stripped → lit/_pdfs/hea-oxygen-ductility/PMC9925791.txt (XML kept beside it). Figures and Supplementary Information (Supp. Figs. 1–15, Tables 1–4) not seen |
Oxygen × Nb ladder; tensile yield and elongation; where oxygen sits; grain-boundary segregation; fracture mode |
| W1 | Wang Q., Wang Z., Zhang, Wang R., Wang T., Ma, Li, Han, Luan, Jiao Z. & Liaw, "Achieving High Damping Capacity in Oxygen-Enhanced BCCBody-centered cubic — Fe/steel common; plasticity more temperature-sensitive. Zr-Hf-Ti-Nb Multi-Principal-Element Alloys with Low Young's Modulus," Advanced Science 12 (2025) 2501068, doi:10.1002/advs.202501068 (CC BY 4.0) | Europe PMC full-text XML (PMC12225015; HTTP 200) → lit/_pdfs/hea-oxygen-ductility/PMC12225015.txt (XML beside it). Figures and Supporting Information (Table S1) not seen |
Hf-bearing check: tensile yield and elongation at 0–1.8 at.% O in three hosts; ω precipitation |
| (re-used) | B1 (Beaudry et al. 2024) and I1 (İroç 2022 thesis) from 2026-10-27 (lit/_pdfs/hea-oxygen/) |
Captures only | Contrast in §3 |
Weakness of the copies, stated plainly. Both are repository XML of the published articles; numbers that exist only in figures or supplements are not used. J1 gives the tensile results as "typical" curves; how many bars per alloy were pulled is not stated in the prose I read. J1's measured oxygen contents are in Supplementary Table 4, which I did not see; the prose says only that "The actual oxygen content is slightly higher than the nominal one".
1.2 Not opened (do not treat as read)
- Lei et al. 2018 (Nature 563: 546–550, ordered oxygen complexes in TiZrHfNb): OpenAlex reports
is_oa: false,oa_status: closed, no repository full text; Europe PMC lists "Subscription required". Not routed around. Enters only as J1 restates it. - Lei et al. 2020 (Sci. Adv. 6: eaba7802, PMC7299626): open, not opened tonight (damping, not a ductility ladder); next candidate if the TiZrHfNb baseline is needed.
- J1 and W1 supplements (J1 Supp. Table 4, measured O; Supp. Fig. 1, the 10/18/22/30 Nb curves; Supp. Fig. 14, fracture surfaces; W1 Table S1).
- Iroc et al. 2022 (Mater. Des. body) and Borges, Ritchie & Asta 2026: not retried.
- Wei et al. 2011 (Mater. Des. 32: 2934, "Influence of oxygen content on microstructure and mechanical properties of Ti-Nb-Ta-Zr alloy", J1's ref. 9): seen only as a reference title.
2. Sourced materials
2.1 The ladder and how it was made (J1)
- Alloys: "Ti–30Zr– x Nb– y O ( x = 10, 14, 18, 22, 26, and 30 at.%, and y = 0, 1, 2, 3, 3.5, and 4 at.%)", made "by substituting Ti with a different amount of oxygen".
- Route: arc melting of pure metals and "TiO 2 (99.99 wt.%) in a Ti-gettered high-purity argon atmosphere", "remelted at least six times", drop-cast; tested as cast.
- Dose check: "Supplementary Table 4 presents the inert gas fusion analysis results of oxygen in the as-cast MEAs. The actual oxygen content is slightly higher than the nominal one because of the unavoidable oxygen contamination during the melting process. Nevertheless, the trend in the actual oxygen content is consistent with that of the nominal oxygen value." (Table not seen.)
- Test: room temperature, strain rate 10⁻³ s⁻¹, dog-bone bars with "a gauge length of 20 mm and a cross-section of 1.3 × 5.0 mm 2".
- Phases: "The Ti–30Zr–10Nb MEA shows a dual-phase structure of bcc+α“, whilst a single bcc phase exists in Ti–30Zr–xNb with a larger amount of Nb".
2.2 Strength and ductility against oxygen (J1)
- Ti–30Zr–14Nb: "the addition of 1–3 at.% oxygen in the Ti–30Zr–14Nb MEA not only increases the yield strength but also significantly improves the ductility"; "the elongation is nearly enhanced by ~164%, from ~9.5% for the Ti–30Zr–14Nb base MEA to ~25.1% for the Ti–30Zr–14Nb–3O variant."
- The 3 at.% alloy: "a tensile yield strength of ~1075 MPa and elongation of ~25%"; "The tensile yield strength is enhanced by ~75%".
- The ductility ceiling, as stated: "When the oxygen content exceeds 3.5 at.%, the ductility declines until a brittle fracture occurs." For 14–22 at.% Nb the ductility rises with oxygen and "reaches its maximum in the sample with 3.0 at.% oxygen".
- Higher Nb: "for the Ti–30Zr–26Nb and Ti–30Zr–30Nb MEAs, the ductility increases slightly with the increase of oxygen content", and "excessive addition of oxygen causes obvious embrittlement".
- Lowest Nb: "the ductility dramatically deteriorates with oxygen concentration in the Ti–30Zr–10Nb MEA"; the authors' suggestion: "suppression of the martensite phase transformation or/and twin formation".
- Strength: "the yield strength increases with the oxygen content", fitted by a dilute (Fleischer) law, linear in c^1/2 (Supp. Fig. 12, not seen).
- A "yield-drop phenomenon was recorded in the tensile stress-strain curves of these MEAs after doping oxygen".
2.3 Where the oxygen goes (J1)
- Ordered oxygen complexes (OOCs), "a state between random interstitials and oxides": imaging shows "oxygen prefers to occupy interstitial positions adjacent to light-atom-rich (i.e., Ti and/or Zr) lattice sites".
- Host dependence: "the degree of CSROs decreases with the increase of Nb" (chemical short-range order, Ti/Zr-rich patches). Fraction of oxygen in OOCs at 3 at.% O, from fitting internal-friction peaks: "40.9, 31.9, 28.9, 26.3, and 24.0%" for 14, 18, 22, 26, 30 at.% Nb. Atom-probe cluster density: "8.7 × 10 24 m −3" (14Nb–3O) vs "6.7 × 10 23 m −3" (26Nb–3O).
- Dose dependence at 14 at.% Nb: OOC fraction "from ~14.5% to ~40.9% as the oxygen content is raised from 1 to 3 at.%"; cluster density "from 1.04 × 10 24 m −3" to "8.7 × 10 24 m −3".
- Past the ceiling: "no oxygen segregation at grain boundaries was observed for the Ti–30Zr–14Nb–3O" and "Ti–30Zr–30Nb–2O MEAs"; "O segregation at grain boundaries did occur in Ti–30Zr–14Nb–4O" and "Ti–30Zr–30Nb–3O MEAs", "despite that no oxide was formed in both MEAs". "As a result, the fracture mode changed from ductile fracture (predominantly dimpled rupture) to intergranular brittle fracture mode in these two MEAs".
- Authors' conclusion: "grain boundary embrittlement resulted from oxygen segregation is responsible for the premature fracture behavior and low ductility", and "the solid solubility of O atoms in the current MEAs decreases with the increase of Nb, which is consistent with the DFT calculations".
- Deformation: "the deformation mode of the current MEAs changes from planar slip to wavy slip with the increase in the number density of OOCs".
2.4 Hf-bearing check (W1)
- Hosts from "the composition formula of (Zr,Hf,Ti) 15 Nb 3": Zr14TiNb3 (S1), Zr8Hf6TiNb3 (S2), Zr8Hf4Ti3Nb3 (S3); "all the designed alloys with and without the oxygen additions will be homogenized first" (not as cast, unlike J1).
- Less stable host S2: "the σ YS = 563 MPa of S2‐HT1 increases to σ YS = 670 MPa after the minor‐alloying by 0.5 at% O", but "the ductility is reduced sharply from ε = 17.4% of O‐free alloy to ε = 6.2% of S2‐0.5O, which should be ascribed to the precipitation of brittle ω phase."
- More stable host S3: "The yield strength is enhanced continuously from σ YS = 704 MPa without O to 796 MPa with 0.5 at% O, 896 MPa with 1.0 at% O, and then to 1000 MPa with 1.8 at% O. Meanwhile, the elongation also increases from original ε = 9.2% to 15.1–18.6% (for alloys containing 1.5–1.8 at% O)." Also "only few α'' and ω precipitates appear in 1.8 at% oxygen‐added alloy"; atom probe shows "Zr‐Ti‐O‐, Hf‐Zr‐O‐, and Nb‐Zr‐Ti‐O‐rich clusters".
- W1 stops at 1.8 at.% O: it does not reach a ceiling.
3. Grades and analysis
| Claim | Grade | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| In cast Ti–30Zr–14Nb, 1–3 at.% O raises both yield strength and elongation (~9.5% → ~25.1% at 3 at.%) | STRONG as measured ("typical" curves; bar count not stated) | J1 |
| Past 3.5 at.% O, Ti–30Zr–14Nb loses ductility to brittle fracture | STRONG as measured | J1 |
| The doses are the nominal ones | WEAK as exact values: measured O "slightly higher" than nominal, table unseen; trend preserved per the authors | J1 |
| O piles up at grain boundaries at 14Nb–4O and 30Nb–3O, not at 14Nb–3O or 30Nb–2O; no oxide; fracture turns intergranular | STRONG as observed (atom probe, XRD/fracture surfaces in supplement unseen) | J1 |
| Boundary pile-up causes the ductility loss | WEAK (co-occurrence plus fracture mode; no test that separates it from other changes) | J1 |
| The ceiling moves down as Nb rises (boundary pile-up by 3 at.% O at 30Nb vs 4 at.% at 14Nb) | STRONG as observed for two hosts; finer placement between 3 and 3.5 at.% at 14Nb is NONE (no level in between other than 3.5) | J1 |
| Mechanism: less Ti/Zr-rich short-range order → fewer OOCs → lower O solubility and less ductilisation | WEAK (STEM contrast, DFT on 96-atom cells, a fitted internal-friction decomposition) | J1 |
| In a two-phase host (Ti–30Zr–10Nb), any added O cuts ductility | STRONG as stated (curves in supplement unseen); cause (suppressed martensite/twinning) WEAK, stated as "might" | J1 |
| Hf-bearing Zr8Hf4Ti3Nb3 gains yield (704 → 1000 MPa) and elongation (9.2% → 15.1–18.6%) up to 1.8 at.% O | STRONG as measured (homogenized) | W1 |
| Hf-bearing Zr8Hf6TiNb3 loses ductility at 0.5 at.% O (17.4% → 6.2%) via ω | STRONG as measured; ω as the cause WEAK-to-STRONG (observed precipitates, causal link asserted) | W1 |
| A ductility ceiling in TiZrHfNbTa (or any Ta-bearing alloy) | NONE | — |
Answer to OQ2 (analysis). Answered for one alloy family, not for the target. In Ti–30Zr–14Nb cast and pulled at room temperature, the ductility window opens at 1 at.% O, peaks at 3 at.% and closes past 3.5 at.% (nominal). The closing comes with oxygen reaching grain boundaries, not with a new phase or oxide. So the edge is a ductility edge inside the single-phase range.
Two ceilings, not one (analysis, across sources). Last night's B1 put NbTiZr's phase ceiling at ~8–10 at.% O (computed, 1050 °C), with a still-bcc base metal measured at 6.7 at.%. J1's ductility ceiling in Ti–30Zr–14Nb is ~3.5 at.% (nominal), with the alloy still one bcc phase and no oxide. If those numbers were in the same alloy, the useful window would end at less than half the dose where the crystal breaks up. They are not the same alloy (Ti-rich vs equimolar Nb-Ti-Zr; as cast vs 1050 °C air exposure; tensile vs nanoindentation), so this is a design warning, not a measured gap ( HYPOTHESIS, mine): B1's report of no cracking at its indents should not be read as ductility at 6.7 at.% O.
Host decides the ceiling (analysis). Both sources say the same thing in different hosts: the same oxygen dose helps one host and wrecks another. J1: raising Nb from 14 to 30 at.% lowers the boundary pile-up dose from 4 to 3 at.% and shrinks the ductility gain; dropping to 10 at.% Nb (two phases) removes the gain entirely. W1: at 0.5 at.% O, one Hf-bearing host loses two-thirds of its elongation (ω), while a more stable one keeps gaining to 1.8 at.%. This answers OQ3 only in part: Hf is present in W1, but W1 varies Hf together with Zr and Ti and stops at 1.8 at.% O, so "Hf moves the ceiling" is NONE; "phase stability of the host moves the ceiling" is STRONG as observed in two families.
Tie to I1 (analysis). İroç's Ti25Zr35Nb20Hf5Ta15 at nominal 2 at.% O compressed past 35% strain without fracture. J1 says 2 at.% sits inside the window for Ti–30Zr–14Nb to Ti–30Zr–30Nb. That is consistent, but compression is lenient and the hosts differ; it does not place TiZrHfNbTa's ceiling.
Design-relevant reading (analysis). (1) A dose ladder should be run past the strength optimum, at ≈0.5 at.% steps, because the drop from best to brittle happens within ~1 at.% (J1: 3 → >3.5). (2) Check grain boundaries (atom probe) at the top dose before trusting single-phase XRD as a sign of safety. (3) Check the host's phase stability (ω, α″) first: W1 shows 0.5 at.% O can be the ceiling in the wrong host. All three are HYPOTHESES for design practice, drawn from these sources.
Counting rule. Only contradicting data count. None of the opened sources contradicts another on a measured number; the B1–J1 comparison is across alloys and flagged as such.
SPECULATIVE Cross-domain section. Open after the materials.
4. Bridge A — SPECULATIVE (after the materials)
Bridge A (locked): doping concentration windows and over-doping ↔ valencyArity: how many actants a predicate takes; formal vs semantic valency can diverge., argument saturation and over-arity. Shapes only:
- Over-dosing shows where the extra goes, not as a new structure. In J1, past the ceiling the oxygen does not form a new phase; it collects at grain boundaries, the places outside the regular crystal. Shape: once the host's preferred sites are "used", the excess lodges at the edges, and that is what fails. If one wanted a Bridge A shape, it is "over-saturation shows up as material parked outside the regular positions". Shape only; no claim that a boundary is a syntactic position.
- The useful window ends before the structural one. Ductility (J1, ~3.5 at.%) quits before the phase limit (B1, ~8–10 at.%, different alloy). Shape: "still well-formed" and "still works" are two different edges. Shape only.
- Host-relative again. The ceiling moves with Nb (J1) and with phase stability (W1). This repeats the host-relative result of Misfit volume: does the element carry its size? and last night's note.
- Still continuous. 1, 2, 3, 3.5, 4 at.% are positions on a continuous scale; the lock "continuous wt% ≠ discrete arity" holds; nothing here counts slots.
Bridge A pressure: none that forces revision. Bridge A unrevised. No chemical stand-in for a theta role, slot or feature bundle; not a correlate; not a joint field. Merge/Agree not involved. No Navajo remark tonight.
5. Open questions
- Ceiling in a Ta-bearing alloy. A tensile oxygen ladder (≥3 levels past 2 at.%) in TiZrHfNbTa or HfNbTaTiZr; still the target. → Partly answered in Oxygen in a Ta-bearing five-element alloy: one measured tensile pair (2026-10-29): Lei et al. 2020 pulls Ta0.5Nb0.5HfZrTi at measured 0.377 vs 2.241 at.% O, yield ~810 → ~1138 MPa and elongation ~10.8% → ~20% (STRONG); ceiling above ~2.2 at.% (lower bound), location still NONE.
- Measured doses. J1 Supp. Table 4 (gas-fusion O) and Supp. Fig. 14 (fracture surfaces): open the Nature Communications supplement to replace nominal doses with measured ones.
- Lei et al. 2018 baseline. Closed; Lei et al. 2020 (Sci. Adv., PMC7299626, open) may restate TiZrHfNb's O-free and 2 at.% tensile numbers. → Checked in Oxygen in a Ta-bearing five-element alloy: one measured tensile pair (2026-10-29): it does not (cites 2018 for the mechanism only); NONE.
- Ceiling after ageing. Does the 3 at.% optimum survive holds at 600–900 °C (tie to L1's drain and I1's hcp)? → Partly answered in Oxygen in HfNbTaTiZr: measured 0.27 vs 3.24 at.%, stability on ageing (2026-10-30): in HfNbTaTiZr, 3.24 at.% measured O loses single bcc at 900 °C / 1000 h (HCPHexagonal close-packed — fewer primary slip systems; Mg, Ti, Zn often anisotropic. + Nb–Ta-rich bcc, STRONG as observed) while 0.27 at.% keeps it; ductility after ageing NONE.
- Carried: OQ1 and OQ4 of Oxygen added on purpose: a dose window in refractory high-entropy alloys (the Iroc et al. 2022 paper body; ageing of the 2 at.% alloy); OQ2/OQ3 of Trace oxygen and nitrogen leave the solution: age softening in TiVNbTa.
6. Separation
SOURCED (inside metallurgy)
J1: Ti–30Zr–xNb–yO ladder (x = 10–30, y = 0–4), TiO₂ route, as cast; measured O slightly above nominal (table unseen); 14Nb: elongation ~9.5% → ~25.1% at 3O, yield ~1075 MPa (+~75%), brittle past 3.5O; 26/30Nb slight gain then embrittlement; 10Nb (bcc+α″) loses ductility; OOC fractions 40.9–24.0% (14–30Nb, 3O) and 14.5 → 40.9% (1 → 3O, 14Nb); cluster densities; GB segregation at 14Nb–4O and 30Nb–3O, none at 14Nb–3O and 30Nb–2O; no oxide; intergranular fracture. W1: S2 563 → 670 MPa, 17.4% → 6.2% at 0.5O (ω); S3 704 → 1000 MPa, 9.2% → 15.1–18.6% at 1.5–1.8O; homogenized. Lei et al. 2018 only as restated by J1.
ANALYSIS (mine, beside the source)
The grades; the answer to OQ2; the two-ceilings comparison with B1; host-relative reading; tie to I1; design readings.
SPECULATIVE
§4 (Bridge A shapes).
Not claimed
No chemical correlate. No chemical stand-in for a theta role, a feature bundle or a slot. Not a joint field. Bridge A unrevised. Nothing from Lei et al. 2018 beyond J1's restatement, from J1's or W1's supplements, or from Iroc et al. 2022's body. No ductility ceiling claimed for TiZrHfNbTa. No claim that J1's numbers carry over to B1's NbTiZr or to Ta-bearing alloys.
7. Verdict
Does an opened source find an oxygen level past which a group IV–V bcc alloy loses ductility? Yes, in Ti–30Zr–14Nb (J1): ductility rises to 3 at.% nominal O and is lost past 3.5 at.% ( STRONG as measured), with oxygen at grain boundaries and no oxide ( STRONG as observed; causal link WEAK). The ceiling is host-relative (J1 Nb series; W1 Hf-bearing hosts, ω at 0.5 at.% in the less stable one) ( STRONG as observed). It sits below the phase ceiling of NbTiZr (analysis across alloys, HYPOTHESIS). TiZrHfNbTa ceiling: NONE. Bridge A unrevised.
v0 — 2026-10-28 PT, evening. Pointers added: corpus-reading-order row; CONCLUSIONS-v1-addendum paragraph; site-content-map (inventory, slug, near-ready, Path E page row); back-pointer at refractory-hea-oxygen-dose-window §5 OQ2. 2026-10-29: OQ1 partly and OQ3 answered (no) in tanbhfzrti-oxygen-tensile-pair-v0.md. Speculation flagged. Bridge A lock unrevised. No joint field.
Corpus note: tizrnb-oxygen-ductility-ceiling-v0.md. The metallurgy is same-domain description from the sources the note lists as opened: Jiao et al. 2023 (Nature Communications 14: 806, CC BY 4.0) and Wang Q. et al. 2025 (Advanced Science 12: 2501068, CC BY 4.0), each as the Europe PMC full-text XML read as text; figures and supplements were not seen, so the measured oxygen contents (Jiao et al., Supplementary Table 4) are not used and doses are nominal. Quotes are verbatim and machine-checked. Lei et al. 2018 (Nature) is closed and enters only as Jiao et al. restate it. Ti–Zr–Nb and Zr–Hf–Ti–Nb numbers are not claimed for TiZrHfNbTa or for NbTiZr. The grades (STRONG / WEAK / NONE) and the comparisons between sources are analysis, not a declared correlate. The Bridge A section comes after the materials and is speculative. No chemical stand-in for a theta role or a slot. Bridge A unrevised. Not a joint field.