Fleischer/Friedel–Labusch crossover: when does one solute pin a dislocation alone, and when do many pin it together? — materials scout,
What’s claimed and how well supported
- Labels on this page
- STRONG ×11 WEAK ×3 SPECULATIVE ×7 NONE ×3
- Strongest label used
- STRONG
- Main caveat (quoted)
- The Bridge A section and the Navajo remark come after the materials and are ◆ SPECULATIVE.
Counted automatically from the labels printed on this page. Counts are a reading aid, not a grade of the page.
Terms on this page (6), plain-language definitions
- Solute
- Intentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition).
- Dopant
- Intentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase.
- Dislocation
- Line defect enabling plastic slip at realistic stresses; edge vs screw are the two classic geometries.
- Solid solution
- Solute atoms dissolved into the host lattice (substitutional or interstitial) without a separate precipitate phase.
- Host (matrix)
- Majority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material.
- Valency (ling.)
- Arity: how many actants a predicate takes; formal vs semantic valency can diverge.
Definitions quoted from the Chem for linguists primer glossary.
Date: 2026-10-19 PT (weekday research push, evening)
Status: Materials scout. The metallurgy is same-domain description from the sources opened below (REAL inside physical metallurgy). The grades and the arithmetic on the sources' table are my analysis. The Bridge A section and the Navajo remark come after the materials and are SPECULATIVE. Not a correlate. Not a joint field.
Audience: Grant (syntax/semantics; less chemistry). End goal: designing new metal alloys. Takes up open question 1 of Misfit volume: does the element carry its size? (carried from OQ1 of Solute strengthening: host part vs element part), blocked on Oct 15 and Oct 16.
Vocabulary lock kept: percent-level additions are solutesIntentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition). / alloying additions, not dopantsIntentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase. (Doping vs alloying vocabulary).
Does not: claim that a solute, a pinning point or a dislocationLine defect enabling plastic slip at realistic stresses; edge vs screw are the two classic geometries. is an argument, operator, slot, feature bundle or theta role; supply a chemical stand-in for a theta role; invent numbers or quotes; supply the numbers missing from the Leyson & Curtin 2013 abstract; revise Bridge A; run the six-point ranking-edge spec.
Why this note. The solute-strengthening note (Oct 15) recorded two concentration laws inside the corpus: strength ∝ √c for dilute, isolated obstacles (Fleischer-type; Yasi et al.) and strength ∝ c^(2/3) for collective pinning (Labusch-type), and asked where one gives way to the other. The key paper (Leyson & Curtin 2013, "Friedel vs. Labusch") was blocked twice. Tonight the same group's 2017 overview, Solute strengthening in random alloys — itself blocked on Oct 15 (EPFL AWS WAF challenge) — downloaded cleanly as the authors' preprint, and it states the crossover and restates Leyson & Curtin's estimates. Leyson & Curtin's own record is metadata-only (no file).
The case, in plain words. A metal deforms when line defects (dislocations) glide. Solute atoms in the way make that harder. There are two pictures. In the strong-pinning picture (Friedel, Fleischer) each solute near the glide plane is a separate point obstacle: the line hangs up on it, bows out between obstacles, and breaks free solute by solute — strength grows as √c. In the weak-pinning picture (Mott–Nabarro, Labusch) no single solute matters; the line is held by lucky clumps in the random arrangement of many solutes at once — strength grows as c^(2/3). The question is which picture is true at which concentration (and temperature).
What is new (one sentence). The one-solute-one-obstacle (Friedel/Fleischer, √c) regime is the exception, not the dilute default: the old zero-temperature estimate put the crossover at a solute fraction of about 10⁻² ("which has led to the assumption that the strong pinning model is applicable at moderate to low solute concentrations"), but at finite temperature the single-solute barrier (~100–200 meV) is thermally overcome and the crossover drops to c < 10⁻⁴ above 78 K for Al–X and Mg–Al (V1 restating Leyson & Curtin 2013), so "the Friedel model rarely applies for moderate solute/dislocation binding energies" — STRONG as stated by the opened overview — with the strong-pinning picture surviving only for solutes that change the dislocation core (Umax ~1 eV) — WEAK (stated as "may become pertinent", no worked case opened); and the corpus's √c law from Yasi et al. is, in the overview's own words, a model used "to predict trends in solute strengthening at 0 K" ( STRONG), so the earlier "√c dilute / c^(2/3) collective" split should be read as "0 K ranking model / finite-temperature regime at almost all practical concentrations".
1. Sources
1.1 Opened this run
| Key | Source | How read | Used for |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1 | Varvenne, Leyson, Ghazisaeidi & Curtin, "Solute strengthening in random alloys," Acta Mater. 124 (2017) 660–683 | Authors' pre-print (dated May 25, 2016; 33 pp.) from EPFL Infoscience (bitstream 6cd21976-…, identical bytes to record/225978/files/solute_strengthening_in_random_alloys_pre-print.pdf; curl HTTP 200, PDF, no challenge served tonight); pdftotext; two-column text layer with garbled formulas; Eqs. (1)–(3) read on page images of pp. 3–4; Table 1 from -layout. Journal version not checked |
Strong vs weak pinning defined; zero-T Friedel and Labusch laws; transition parameter β and c₀^trans; finite-T crossover (restating Leyson & Curtin 2013); exceptions; c^(2/3) experiments; "clusters"; Yasi et al. as a 0 K model; dilute vs non-dilute reference; Al–Fe failure; bcc softening remark; high-T plateau |
| L1 | Leyson & Curtin 2013, "Friedel vs. Labusch: the strong/weak pinning transition in solute strengthened metals," Phil. Mag. 93: 2428–2444 | Abstract only, from the EPFL Infoscience record (HTML page HTTP 200 tonight, no bot check; public item metadata: datacite.rights = metadata-only; bundles list holds only license.txt, no full-text file). The served abstract has its numbers missing (e.g. "for concentrations greater than and temperatures greater than K"); the numbers are not supplied here from anywhere |
The two qualitative conclusions: core structure governs the temperature dependence of the transition; Labusch controls at engineering conditions except for "the most highly localized cores" |
Verbatim passages: excerpts-verbatim.md (not published here) (cut programmatically by make_excerpts.py, 27 spans, 0 missing); Table 1 block: tables-verbatim.md (not published here); L1 metadata saved as leyson-curtin-2013-epfl-record-abstract.txt plus the item/bundle JSON. Quote fragments in this note machine-checked with check_quotes.py.
1.2 Not opened (do not treat as read)
- Leyson & Curtin 2013 full text. Not on arXiv (search result; an arXiv API query timed out twice tonight and was dropped). Unpaywall and Semantic Scholar list a "green" copy at the EPFL record, but the record tonight is metadata-only with no file. Taylor & Francis not retried (Cloudflare 403 on Oct 16). Its numbers (transition concentration range, temperature threshold) enter only as restated in V1.
- LaRosa, Shih, Varvenne & Ghazisaeidi 2019, "Solid solutionSolute atoms dissolved into the host lattice (substitutional or interstitial) without a separate precipitate phase. strengthening theories of high-entropy alloys," Mater. Charact. 151: 310 (HAL hal-02082220): HAL served a "Making sure you're not a bot!" page to curl. Not routed around; a search-result snippet was seen and not used.
- Leyson, Hector & Curtin 2012 (Acta Mater. 60: 3873, Al–X): no open copy found (search results only); its abstract was seen on an index page and not used.
- Labusch 1970/1972, Friedel 1964, Fleischer 1961/1963, Kratochvíl & Neradová 1971, Zaiser 2002, Argon's book: not opened; enter only as cited in V1.
2. Sourced materials
2.1 The two pictures (V1)
- Strong pinning. "The strong-pinning theory (Friedel [27], Fleischer [28, 29]) considers only solute atoms in the glide plane(s) of the dislocation and treats them as independent point obstacles that pin the dislocation." "The solutes are characterized by Fmax, the maximum resistive force exerted by the solute on the dislocation." The line "bows out in the regions between the solutes".
- Weak pinning. "Recognizing that many solutes can simultaneously exert forces on the dislocation, the weak-pinning model (Mott-Nabarro [30], Mott [31], Labusch [32, 33]) considers the collective interaction of the random solutes with the dislocation. Strengthening is then attributed to the occurrence of favorable statistical fluctuations in the overall solute configuration that locally bind the dislocation much more strongly than any individual solute."
- Zero-temperature laws (page images, pp. 3–4; garbled in the text layer). Friedel: τ_y0^F = (F_max/2Γ)^(3/2) (2Γ/b²) c^(1/2) (Eq. 1). Labusch: τ_y0^L = (F_max⁴ w / 4Γb⁷)^(1/3) c^(2/3) (Eq. 2), with w "a parameter w that represents the spatial range of interaction of the solutes with the dislocation". Γ is the line tension, b the Burgers vector.
- How the winner was picked. "At any given solute concentration, the operative mechanism has historically been assumed to be the mechanism that gives the strongest zerotemperature yield stress. Taking the ratio of Eqs. (1) and (2) yields β 1/6 where β is the transition parameter first identified by Labusch [32, 33]" — β = F_max b² / (4Γ c w²) (Eq. 3, page image). Strong pinning wins when β ≫ 1, weak when β ≪ 1, so the zero-temperature crossover is c₀^trans = F_max b² / (4Γ w²) (page image).
- The old number. "Using typical materials parameters gives a transition concentration ∼ 10−2, which has led to the assumption that the strong pinning model is applicable at moderate to low solute concentrations [32, 34]."
- A structural objection to strong pinning. "The Friedel-type models entirely neglect the longrange interactions, so that even solutes just two atomic planes above or below the glide plane are not considered to exert forces on the dislocation even though their maximum pinning force can be appreciable [37]."
2.2 Finite temperature moves the crossover down by orders of magnitude (V1, restating L1)
- Two energy scales. "The energy scale of the Friedel model is the maximum interaction energy Umax of a single solute with the straight dislocation, independent of solute concentration [18]. As seen in Fig. 1, this energy is typically on the order of ∼ 100 − 200 meV." Hence "the Friedel mechanism has a characteristic temperature T◦F ∼ 100–200 K at which the strength is essentially zero. In contrast, the energy scale of the Labusch model is related to the collective solute fluctuations and scales as ∼ c1/3, and can be much greater than Umax even at moderately low concentrations (c > 10−4 )."
- The crossover. "At finite temperature, the concentration at which there is a transition from the Friedel to the Labusch model, ctrans, is then much smaller than the zero-temperature estimate ctrans." and "Detailed esti0 mates show, for example, that ctrans < 10−4 when T > 78 K for the Al-X (X= Mg, Si, Cu, Cr, Mn and Fe) and the Mg-Al (basal) systems [36]." ([36] = Leyson & Curtin 2013; "esti0 mates" is a text-layer artefact — a subscript 0 fell into the word.) Consequence, in V1's words: "As a result, the Friedel model rarely applies for moderate solute/dislocation binding energies."
- The exception. "For solutes that change the core structure, and with much larger associated interaction energies (e.g. Umax = 1 eV [8]), the Friedel model may become pertinent [27, 32] because the core-changing solutes dominate over all other solute interactions in the far-field and the activation energy barrier is significant." Same point in the Discussion: when solutes strongly distort the core, "the “strong pinning” Fleischer-Friedel models may become operative, with individual solutes in the very core of the dislocation providing much stronger pinning than that of the collective effect of the surrounding solutes."
- L1's own abstract (numbers missing as served). "the temperature dependence of the transition concentration greatly depends on the dislocation core structure and, in general, can differ significantly from the zero-temperature value. The zero-temperature transition concentration itself also differs from the standard estimate." And: "Except for the most highly localized cores, the Labusch model controls the strengthening" … "Overall, at temperatures and concentrations relevant to engineering applications, the Labusch model is therefore expected to control the strengthening mechanisms for these alloys and for most dislocation core structures in metals."
2.3 Experiments and the "cluster" patch (V1)
- "Earlier, Kratchovil and Neradova [43] showed that the (extrapolated) zero-temperature strength scales with solute concentration as c2/3, as predicted by the Labusch model." (Primary not opened; spelling as printed in the preprint.)
- "when the Friedel model based on pinning by individual solute atoms has failed to quantitatively explain experiments, researchers have postulated the existence of solute “clusters” as the operative pinning points within a Friedel-type model [51, 52, 53]. These experiments are, however, well-interpreted in terms of the Labusch-type models."
- The new theory keeps the collective scalings: "The scalings with solute concentration τy0 ∝ c2/3 and ∆Eb ∝ c1/3 are similar to those found in the historical collective pinning models [30, 32, 33, 57]." Table 1 (fits to experiment, tables-verbatim.md (not published here)): ΔE_b/c^(1/3) = 3.96 (Cu–Al), 3.02 (Cu–Ge), 4.01 (Cu–Mn), 4.30 (Ag–Al) eV; τ_y0/c^(2/3) = 187.3, 227.2, 415.5, 97.2 MPa.
2.4 The corpus's √c law, re-read (V1 on Yasi et al.)
The Oct 15 note's √c law came from Yasi, Hector & Trinkle (arXiv:1007.2585; their "dilute-concentration, weak-obstacle model … from Fleischer"). V1 describes that same work ([39] = Yasi, Hector & Trinkle): "For purposes of guiding alloy design, i.e. selection of solutes, Trinkle et al. [39] devised two quantitative measures for the solute/dislocation interaction energy, a misfit volume parameter and a solute/stacking fault interaction parameter, and used these parameters in Fleischer/Friedel-type model to predict trends in solute strengthening at 0 K." And Mg–Al (basal) is one of the systems with ctrans < 10⁻⁴ above 78 K (§2.2). So the √c law in the corpus is a zero-temperature ranking device for choosing solutes, not a claim that dilute Mg alloys at room temperature are in the strong-pinning regime. (Yasi et al. themselves call it "weak-obstacle"; the naming varies across papers — V1 groups Fleischer with strong pinning. I record the clash and do not resolve it.)
2.5 Host, reference and the limits of the theory (V1)
- Dilute = a real hostMajority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material.. In the dilute limit "Each solute n is therefore only surrounded by n0 -type atoms, so the fluctuations of solute/dislocation interactions due to the different possible local chemical and structural environment disappear". Otherwise "when the concentrations of alloying elements are non-dilute, there is not one major element nor can the real solid solution be considered as a small perturbation of the matrix of one of the elements" (consistent with the Oct 15/16 notes).
- A ppm failure. "The measured strengths of Al-Fe at Fe contents of 10-50 ppm are, while small, roughly 10 times larger than predicted by the theory. Analysis of the DFT provides no insights into the reasons for this failure of the theory." V1 lists possible effects still to be investigated (interaction of Fe with O or other impurities, strong Fe–Fe pairs; paraphrase — the sentence is split by a page header in the text layer), and draws the lesson that "the strengthening mechanism envisioned in the theory may not be applicable even when first-principles DFT results do not indicate any anomalous behavior in the solute/dislocation interaction energies."
- Softening is outside this theory's materials. "In materials such as bcc alloys, the Peierls stress of the pure material (or the effective matrix material) is high. Thus, solutes can soften and strengthen" — flagged by V1 as future work, not modelled.
- Concentration-dependent plateau. The high-temperature "plateau" "is, however, dependent on solute concentration itself"; in the new theory a second energy minimum of the dislocation's wavy configuration takes over: "The first minimum thus controls the strength at lower temperatures while the second minimum controls the strength at higher temperatures, with low and high depending on the precise material values."
- Solute pairs at higher concentration. Atomistic studies identified the "role of solute pairs when the solute concentration increases and the reference is taken from a pure elemental matrix" (listed, not developed).
3. Grading (analysis)
The question (OQ1). At what concentration (and for which solute strengths) does the √c (Fleischer/Friedel, independent obstacles) law give way to the c^(2/3) (Labusch, collective) law?
| Claim | Grade | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| The zero-temperature crossover is c₀^trans = F_max b²/(4Γw²), historically ~10⁻² | STRONG (as a stated historical estimate) | V1 Eqs. (1)–(3), page images; "∼ 10−2" with "typical materials parameters"; L1 says the zero-T value "itself also differs from the standard estimate" (direction and size not readable — numbers missing) |
| At finite temperature the crossover falls far below c₀^trans; Labusch controls for c ≳ 10⁻⁴ above 78 K in Al–X and Mg–Al | STRONG in the opened overview; numbers are V1's restatement of L1, primary not read | V1 §2 (energy scales; "ctrans < 10−4 when T > 78 K"); L1 abstract agrees qualitatively ("at temperatures and concentrations relevant to engineering applications, the Labusch model is therefore expected to control") |
| The independent-obstacle (one solute, one pin) regime "rarely applies" for moderate binding | STRONG | V1 wording; physical reason stated (single-solute barrier ~100–200 meV, T◦F ~100–200 K) |
| Strong pinning survives for core-changing solutes (Umax ~1 eV) or "the most highly localized cores" | WEAK | Stated as "may become pertinent" / "may become operative" (V1) and as an exception (L1); no worked material case opened |
| Collective c^(2/3) is seen experimentally | STRONG (restated) | Kratochvíl & Neradová via V1; V1 Table 1 fits to four dilute fcc binaries; "clusters" patch for Friedel better read as Labusch (V1) |
| The corpus's √c law (Yasi et al.) is a 0 K trend model for ranking solutes | STRONG | V1's description of [39]; Mg–Al basal in the c_trans < 10⁻⁴ list |
| The crossover itself is set by the host's defect (core structure, line tension) together with the solute's force | STRONG for the zero-T formula (F_max from solute-in-host; Γ, b, w from host and core); STRONG for "temperature dependence … greatly depends on the dislocation core structure" (L1 words); my reading that this is the same host/solute split as Oct 15 is analysis | |
| Over-concentration softening inside an fcc random solid solution | NONE (still) | Nothing in V1; c^(2/3) has no ceiling in the theory; softening mentioned only for high-Peierls (bcc) materials, outside the model |
| The Al–Fe ppm failure is a strong-pinning (sub-crossover) effect | NONE — not claimed by the source | V1 gives no reason; see OQ2 |
Arithmetic check (mine, indicative only). With V1's fitted ΔE_b/c^(1/3) of 3.02–4.30 eV (Table 1, Cu- and Ag-based binaries), the collective barrier at c = 10⁻⁴ is 3.02–4.30 × (10⁻⁴)^(1/3) ≈ 0.14–0.20 eV — about the single-solute Friedel scale of ~100–200 meV that V1 quotes from its Fig. 1 (Al and Mg hosts) — and ≈ 0.30–0.43 eV at 10⁻³, ≈ 0.65–0.93 eV at 10⁻². So the two energy scales meet near 10⁻⁴, the same order as the restated crossover. This mixes fitted Cu/Ag numbers with computed Al/Mg energies and is not a derivation of c_trans.
Correction to the Oct 15 note (flagged, earlier note left as written). Solute strengthening: host part vs element part §2.4 item 1 lists "Dilute, isolated obstacles (Fleischer-type): strength ∝ √c" as the dilute regime. Per V1 that law is a 0 K trend model; at finite temperature the collective regime starts at or below ~10⁻⁴ for the systems estimated, so "dilute" in the usual alloy sense (0.1–several at%) is already Labusch territory. The back-pointer at that note's OQ1 records this.
Counting rule. Only contradicting data count: the restated c_trans < 10⁻⁴, V1's "rarely applies", and the experiments read as c^(2/3) are what move the old "√c at low concentration" picture. Silence (no opened source testing a core-changing solute) is not counted against the exception.
SPECULATIVE Cross-domain section. Open after the materials.
4. Bridge A — SPECULATIVE (after the materials)
Bridge A (locked): doping concentration windows and over-doping ↔ valencyArity: how many actants a predicate takes; formal vs semantic valency can diverge., argument saturation and over-arity. What tonight adds, as shape only:
- The one-filler-one-slot picture is the narrow regime. The regime that looks most like counting fillers into places one at a time (each solute its own pin, √c) holds only near 0 K, below ~10⁻⁴, or for core-changing solutes. Everywhere practical, strength comes from statistical fluctuations of many fillers at once, with no individual solute being the obstacle. On the Bridge A side this cuts against reading solute strengthening as slot filling up to saturation: there is no discrete count of places to fill, and the law (c^(2/3)) keeps rising without a ceiling inside the solid solution. This agrees with the Oct 15 finding that the window edge here is the solubility ceiling, not slot saturation. Lock "continuous wt% ≠ discrete arity" holds.
- A regime switch set by the frame. Which picture applies is decided by a ratio (β) of the solute's force to the host's line tension and interaction range, and its temperature dependence "greatly depends on the dislocation core structure" (L1). Shape only: the host's defect, not the filler, mostly decides whether fillers act one by one or collectively. No linguistic mechanism is claimed to match this.
- Winner-takes-all selection was the old assumption. Historically the mechanism with the larger 0 K stress was assumed to operate; the finite-temperature treatment replaced that rule. Shape only; not a ranking-edge result and not a theta stand-in.
Navajo remark ( SPECULATIVE, one paragraph). On Navajo Decoded, the working picture (Grant's open hypothesis, weaker version supported by the ranking results) is that the verb takes role-bearing pronoun slots and nouns link to those slots. The nearest materials shape to slot-by-slot linking is strong pinning — one filler, one place — and tonight's sources say that shape is the rare regime in metals. This is not evidence about Navajo either way: per the counting rule, nothing here is language data, and a metal's dislocation has no slots. No chemical stand-in for a theta role, slot or feature bundle; not a correlate; Bridge A unrevised; not a joint field.
5. Open questions
- Leyson & Curtin 2013 numbers directly. The served abstract has its numbers missing; the full text is not openly available tonight. The crossover range and temperature threshold enter only via V1.
- Al–Fe at 10–50 ppm. The theory under-predicts by ~10× at concentrations (1–5 × 10⁻⁵) at or below the restated crossover bound. Is this a strong-pinning, Fe–impurity or Fe–Fe-pair effect? V1 does not say; nothing is claimed here.
- A worked core-changing case. Which solute–host pair is an opened example of Umax ~1 eV strong pinning? (V1's [8]–[10] not opened.)
- The naming clash. Yasi et al. call their Fleischer model "weak-obstacle"; V1 files Fleischer under strong pinning. Check a primary (Fleischer 1963 or Labusch 1970) for the convention. → Touched 2026-10-20 evening in Concentrated alloys: one solute alone or many together, with no host?: Zhai & Zaiser (arXiv:1807.09512) give a secondary convention — strong/weak means whether the line bends around each pin individually, not how high the stress is — which fits V1's filing; the Yasi usage is still unexplained; primary still needed.
- Concentrated alloys. Does the crossover question even arise in high-entropy alloys, where there is no host? V1 treats all elements as solutes in an average matrix; the HAL review (LaRosa et al. 2019) was blocked. → Taken up 2026-10-20 evening in Concentrated alloys: one solute alone or many together, with no host?: not in its dilute form — the Varvenne, Luque & Curtin 2016 theory (pre-print) makes every element a "solute" in an average matrix at 100% solute concentration, collective by construction (STRONG), and Zhai & Zaiser estimate Cantor well inside the weak regime (STRONG; TaNbHfZrTi borderline, WEAK); but the question returns one level down, as individual Co–Cr pinning points in simulated random CoCrFeMnNi (Utt et al. 2022; STRONG as simulated, WEAK as controlling strength).
- Carried from misfit-volume portability: OQ2–OQ6 there unchanged (family width; concentration shift of apparent volume; P6 vs P1/P2; King/Lubarda primaries; process side).
6. Separation
SOURCED (inside metallurgy)
Strong vs weak pinning defined; Eqs. (1)–(3) and c₀^trans; the ~10⁻² historical estimate; long-range objection to Friedel; Friedel and Labusch energy scales, T◦F; c_trans < 10⁻⁴ above 78 K for Al–X and Mg–Al (restating L1); "rarely applies"; the core-changing exception; Kratochvíl & Neradová c^(2/3) (restated); the "clusters" patch; Table 1 fits; Yasi et al. as a 0 K trend model; dilute vs non-dilute reference; the Al–Fe failure; bcc soften-and-strengthen remark; concentration-dependent plateau and two minima; solute pairs (V1). Core-structure dependence and engineering-regime conclusion (L1 abstract, numbers missing).
ANALYSIS (mine, beside the sources)
The grades in §3; the energy-scale arithmetic on Table 1; the correction to the Oct 15 §2.4 reading; the host/solute reading of c₀^trans; the naming-clash observation.
SPECULATIVE
§4 (Bridge A shapes; Navajo remark). Grant's slot/feature-bundle and layered-assignment ideas remain his open hypotheses.
Not claimed
No chemical correlate. No chemical stand-in for a theta role, a feature bundle or a slot. Not a joint field. Bridge A unrevised. No number from Leyson & Curtin 2013 beyond what V1 restates. Nothing from the blocked or unopened sources (LaRosa et al. HAL review; Leyson, Hector & Curtin 2012; primaries cited in V1) used as evidence.
7. Verdict
Where does √c give way to c^(2/3)? At zero temperature the textbook estimate is a solute fraction of about 10⁻², which is why strong (one-solute-one-obstacle) pinning was assumed for low concentrations; but the single-solute barrier is only ~100–200 meV, so at finite temperature the collective (Labusch) regime takes over at much lower concentrations — c < 10⁻⁴ above 78 K for Al–X and Mg–Al, in the overview's restatement of Leyson & Curtin — and "the Friedel model rarely applies for moderate solute/dislocation binding energies" ( STRONG, V1; L1 abstract agrees in words). The strong-pinning picture is kept only for core-changing solutes or highly localized cores ( WEAK, no worked case opened). The corpus's √c law (Yasi et al.) is a 0 K solute-ranking model ( STRONG, V1), so the Oct 15 split is corrected to "0 K ranking device vs the finite-temperature regime at nearly all practical concentrations". No over-concentration softening inside an fcc solid solution is shown ( NONE). OQ1 is answered in order of magnitude via the overview; the primary's own numbers remain unread.
v0 — 2026-10-19 PT, evening. Pointers added: corpus-reading-order row; CONCLUSIONS-v1-addendum paragraph; site-content-map (inventory, Path E list, slug, near-ready, Path E page row; misfit-volume-portability row marked live); back-pointers at misfit-volume-portability OQ1 and solute-strengthening-slot-vs-element OQ1. Speculation flagged. Bridge A lock unrevised. No joint field.
Corpus note: fleischer-labusch-crossover-v0.md. The metallurgy is same-domain description from the sources the note lists as opened (the Varvenne et al. 2017 overview as the authors' pre-print; the Leyson & Curtin 2013 abstract as served by its repository record, with its numbers missing and not supplied); blocked and unopened sources are listed and not used. The crossover numbers are the overview's restatement of Leyson & Curtin, whose full text was not opened. The energy-scale arithmetic is marked as the note's own. The grades (STRONG / WEAK / NONE) are analysis, not a declared correlate. The Bridge A section and the Navajo remark come after the materials and are speculative. No chemical stand-in for a theta role or a slot. Bridge A unrevised. Not a joint field.