No joint field · Bridge A = SPECULATIVE pedagogy

Labels: SOURCED HYPOTHESIS SPECULATIVE OPEN NONE (REAL = same-domain materials or linguistics, shown like SOURCED)

Explore · prototype

Node-movement view

Built from export/host-systems.csv: 108 rows marked checked = yes, across 11 host systems. Unchecked rows are left out. Grades (STRONG, WEAK, NONE) are the CSV’s evidence grades.

Host systems

HfNbTaTiZr refractory HEA

26 checked rows

  • host: HfNbTaTiZr refractory HEA
    • site: interstitial (as the CSV writes it)
      • added: O (interstitial)
        • window: 3.24 at.%; -3% STRONG
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: Measured O is 0.27 (base) and 3.24 at.% (-3%O) [grade as written: STRONG as measured (with stated ±); basis: P1 Table 1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: Both alloys start single bcc [grade as written: STRONG as observed (EBSD); basis: P1] source note
        • window: 0.27 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: Base (0.27 at.% O) stays single bcc after 1000 h at 900 °C under Ar [grade as written: STRONG as observed (repeated twice, identical); basis: P1] source note
        • window: 3.24 at.%; .% STRONG
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: 3.24 at.% O breaks down at 900 °C / 1000 h into HCP + Nb–Ta-rich bcc, ~15 + ~35 vol.% [grade as written: STRONG as observed (one condition; fractions from 2D area converted by the authors); basis: P1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: Oxygen is the cause of the breakdown at 900 °C [grade as written: STRONG as a comparison (same base clean vs contaminated vs O added; O partitions to HCP); the oxygen dose at which it starts NONE (two levels); basis: P1] source note
        • window: 3.24 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: Continuous HCP layer on grain boundaries of aged 3.24 at.% O alloy [grade as written: STRONG as observed; basis: P1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: Monotectoid / bcc miscibility-gap mechanism [grade as written: WEAK (the authors' interpretation; qualitative diagram, ThermoCalc database "not optimized"); basis: P1] source note
        • window: 3.24 at.%; ~40% WEAK
          • mechanism: other (phase stability / ageing)
          • effect: 3.24 at.% O alloy cracks on cold rotary swaging at ~40% reduction [grade as written: WEAK (one attempt, acknowledgments only, no detail on the starting state or the cracks); basis: P1] source note
    • site: nothing added
      • added: none added (spinodal + nano-hcp at 873 K)
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: At 873 K the solutionized alloy splits into Zr–Hf-rich bcc1 and Nb–Ta-rich bcc2 (Ti even), ~10 nm modulation [grade as written: STRONG as observed (HAADF-STEM + EDS); "spinodal" is the authors' reading, WEAK→STRONG (fits the <100> alignment and the Zr–Nb analogy they cite); basis: Y4] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: <10 nm hcp precipitates from bcc1, aligned on {100}bcc [grade as written: STRONG as observed (SAED, dark field, HRTEM/FFT); basis: Y4] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: Hardness is already high after 0.2 h at 873 K [grade as written: STRONG as stated (number in a figure only; not used); basis: Y4] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: The 873 K rise appears with an 1800 s hold and becomes insignificant with a 120 s hold and fast heating, same polycrystals and strain rate [grade as written: STRONG as a same-batch contrast (compression; magnitudes in a figure only); basis: Y4] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: The nano-hcp, not the bcc1/bcc2 split alone, causes the rise [grade as written: STRONG within compression (suppression test + no rise at 1073 K where the split occurs without hcp); basis: Y4] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: Rise of 560 MPa between 673 and 873 K in single crystals [grade as written: WEAK here (restated from the unopened 2021 paper); basis: Y4 restating [13]] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: At 1073 K the bcc decomposes but no hcp forms [grade as written: WEAK here (restated from [13]); basis: Y4] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: Grain-boundary bcc2 slows the hcp and weakens the rise in polycrystals [grade as written: WEAK (authors' reading; one supporting hardness remark restated from [13]); basis: Y4] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: precipitation
          • effect: Oxygen content of Y4's alloy [grade as written: NONE (not mentioned); basis: Y4] source note
    • site: no single host: concentrated / multi-principal
      • added: concentrated multi-principal (all elements)
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: HfNbTaTiZr compression yield 1670 → ~1150 MPa from 77 → 298 K; knee above 298 K [grade as written: STRONG as measured (one alloy, 3 temperatures in zone I; prose + table, figure not seen); basis: H1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: That zone I yield is screw-controlled (thermally activated screw motion) [grade as written: WEAK in tonight's sources — an inference from the temperature dependence (H1) and a Peierls fit (C1); no dislocation imaging in either. Couzinié 2015 (unopened) is cited for slip-only at 298 K; basis: H1; C1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: Tensile yield keeps falling through 573 and 673 K [grade as written: STRONG as measured (C1 prose; values only in an unseen figure); basis: C1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: A flat (athermal) stretch exists, at 873–1073 K, 481 vs 461 MPa [grade as written: WEAK as a plateau — two points, nothing measured 298–873 K, and H1 itself places 1073 K in the diffusional zone; basis: H1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: No yield drop at 1073 K (unlike NbTiZr's E1 drop) [grade as written: STRONG for this compression test at 10⁻³ s⁻¹; but strain softening after 1.6 % and (as restated) rate dependence at 1073 K; basis: H1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: 1073 K is diffusional (recovery, climb, grain-boundary sliding; no kink bands) [grade as written: STRONG as observed (curve shape, grain shape, EBSD); mechanism names WEAK ("can contribute", "might"); basis: H1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: DSA between 298 and 673 K: serrations at 673 K, anomalous hardening rise [grade as written: STRONG as observed; DSA as the cause WEAK (by elimination; solute not named; fit-based split); basis: C1] source note
        • window: .ppm WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: Dissolved O (5300 at.ppm) raises RT strength [grade as written: WEAK ("It is likely"; processing also differs); basis: H1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (concentrated)
          • effect: HfNbTaTiZr is chemically non-uniform at the nm scale even after homogenization (Ta/Zr) [grade as written: STRONG as measured (one APT tip); basis: H1] source note

NbTiZr bcc alloy

9 checked rows

  • host: NbTiZr bcc alloy
    • site: no single host: concentrated / multi-principal
      • added: concentrated multi-principal
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: Equiatomic NbTiZr deforms by screw-dislocation slip (no twinning), 77–873 K [grade as written: STRONG for this alloy (TEM after 2–3% strain; one study); basis: E1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: Edge strengthening is limited in NbTiZr (so the screw/edge split for this Ti-Zr-Nb alloy favours screws) [grade as written: WEAK — stated in E1's main text; the edge-theory numbers are in the unopened supplement. Fits BMC's misfit rule (abstract) and E1's TEM; basis: E1; BMC] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: YS: steep 77→300 K (1410→630 MPa), plateau 300–873 K, drop at 1073 K [grade as written: STRONG as measured (tension, one alloy, one strain rate; prose only, figure not seen). Compression data (Senkov) higher — level depends on test, shape is what matters here; basis: E1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: The plateau is cross-kink strengthening [grade as written: WEAK — indirect: activation-volume trend agrees with a theory whose NbTiZr parameters were fitted to other (Senkov) data; debris/loops at 473 K fit the break-away picture; V∗ at 473 K unexplained (PLC); no atomistic observation. No opened contradicting data; basis: E1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: Cross-kinks are lost at high T: at 1073 K straight, cross-kink-free dislocations, no debris, strength drop [grade as written: STRONG as observation (one alloy, one temperature above the plateau); basis: E1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: What defeats the locks is vacancies (diffusion) [grade as written: WEAK — temperature, not vacancy concentration, was varied; recovery/climb co-present; two diffusional stories (vacancy cross-kink glide vs edge-dipole climb) not separated; basis: E1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: An opened source gives separate screw and edge strengths for TaNbHfZrTi [grade as written: NONE; basis: B1 has cores only; BMC body not opened] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: HfNbTaTiZr screw cores vary (compact / split) with local chemistry [grade as written: STRONG as computed (DFT; few dipole configurations; cells of 462 atoms); basis: B1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (screw dislocation)
          • effect: HfNbTaTiZr is screw-controlled [grade as written: WEAK here — only as B1 restates TEM work (not opened); M1 (last night) restated edge dominance at the start of flow; basis: B1; M1] source note

Ta20Nb20Hf20Zr20Ti20 (HfNbTaTiZr) refractory HEA

11 checked rows

  • host: Ta20Nb20Hf20Zr20Ti20 (HfNbTaTiZr) refractory HEA
    • site: nothing added
      • added: none added (HIP-formed Zr-Hf-rich HCP phase)
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: As cast (both routes) the alloy is single bcc [grade as written: STRONG as observed (SEM + XRD); basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: After HIP at 1230 °C / 152 MPa / 4 h a Zr–Hf-rich HCP phase is present beside a Nb–Ta–Ti bcc matrix [grade as written: STRONG as observed (SEM + XRD + EDS, both routes); basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: HCP evenly dispersed (gravity) vs mostly on grain boundaries (suction) [grade as written: STRONG as observed; basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: HIP raises hardness ~324–330 → ~437–509 HV [grade as written: STRONG as measured (ten indents each); basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: Room-temperature tensile elongation of the HIP'd alloy is below detection; fracture inter-crystalline, no plasticity [grade as written: STRONG as measured (five bars, two routes); basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: Tension σmax 669–749 MPa vs compression σy 1350–1888 MPa [grade as written: STRONG as measured (column reading of Table 2 WEAK; prose supports); basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: Slow furnace cooling after HIP formed the HCP phase [grade as written: WEAK (authors' reading, untested; cooling not given in methods); basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: The HCP phase caused the tensile brittleness [grade as written: HYPOTHESIS (authors do not claim it; mechanism "further research"); the cause is NONE as sourced; basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: Oxygen content of L3's alloy [grade as written: NONE (not measured); basis: L3] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV HYPOTHESIS (HYPOTHESIS (ungraded))
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: Oxygen drove L3's HCP phase or its brittleness [grade as written: HYPOTHESIS (P1 says discrepancies "may be related" to oxygen; not tested on L3's material); basis: P1 + L3] source note
        • window: 4.7%; 86.4% WEAK
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (second-phase embrittlement)
          • effect: The same nominal alloy is ductile in a wrought single-bcc state (4.7% after 86.4% cold rolling) [grade as written: WEAK here (restated by L3 from an unopened paper; P1 agrees in words); basis: L3 restating Senkov & Semiatin 2015; P1] source note

TaNbHfZrTi refractory HEA

9 checked rows

  • host: TaNbHfZrTi refractory HEA
    • site: interstitial (as the CSV writes it)
      • added: O (interstitial)
        • window: 2.241 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Measured O is 0.377 (base) and 2.241 at.% (O-2) [grade as written: STRONG as measured (one gas-fusion value each; spread not given); basis: L2-S Table S1] source note
        • window: ~40% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Base → O-2: yield ~810 → ~1138 MPa (+~40%, my arithmetic) [grade as written: STRONG as measured (one curve per alloy shown; bar count not stated); basis: L2] source note
        • window: ~10.8%; ~20% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Base → O-2: elongation ~10.8% → ~20% [grade as written: STRONG as measured; the exact top value WEAK ("~20%" and "doubled"; 20/10.8 ≈ 1.85, my arithmetic); basis: L2] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Single bcc at both levels; similar grain size [grade as written: STRONG as observed (XRD, EBSD); basis: L2] source note
        • window: ~18.5% WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: ~18.5% of the oxygen sits in ordered complexes [grade as written: WEAK (a two-class fit to broadened damping peaks; the authors call full deconvolution "difficult"); basis: L2] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Ordered complexes cause the ductility gain [grade as written: WEAK (the authors' attribution, resting on Lei et al. 2018, which is closed here); basis: L2] source note
        • window: ~2.2 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Ductility ceiling in Ta0.5Nb0.5HfZrTi lies above ~2.2 at.% O [grade as written: STRONG as a lower bound (ductility still rising at 2.241 at.%); basis: L2 + L2-S] source note
        • window: 2 at.% NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: L2 restates Lei et al. 2018's TiZrHfNb O-free vs 2 at.% tensile numbers [grade as written: NONE (cited for the mechanism only); basis: L2] source note
        • window: ~20% NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: One alloy reaches ~1400 MPa yield and ~20% elongation [grade as written: NONE in the body: N-2 has 1362 MPa with ~11.9%; O-2 has 1138 MPa with ~20%. The abstract sentence pairs the two; basis: L2 (internal check)] source note

Ti-Zr-Nb / Zr-Hf-Ti-Nb medium/multi-principal bcc alloys

10 checked rows

  • host: Ti-Zr-Nb / Zr-Hf-Ti-Nb medium/multi-principal bcc alloys
    • site: interstitial (as the CSV writes it)
      • added: O (interstitial)
        • window: 1–3 at.%; ~9.5%; ~25.1%; 3 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: In cast Ti–30Zr–14Nb, 1–3 at.% O raises both yield strength and elongation (~9.5% → ~25.1% at 3 at.%) [grade as written: STRONG as measured ("typical" curves; bar count not stated); basis: J1] source note
        • window: 3.5 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: Past 3.5 at.% O, Ti–30Zr–14Nb loses ductility to brittle fracture [grade as written: STRONG as measured; basis: J1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: The doses are the nominal ones [grade as written: WEAK as exact values: measured O "slightly higher" than nominal, table unseen; trend preserved per the authors; basis: J1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: O piles up at grain boundaries at 14Nb–4O and 30Nb–3O, not at 14Nb–3O or 30Nb–2O; no oxide; fracture turns intergranular [grade as written: STRONG as observed (atom probe, XRD/fracture surfaces in supplement unseen); basis: J1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: Boundary pile-up causes the ductility loss [grade as written: WEAK (co-occurrence plus fracture mode; no test that separates it from other changes); basis: J1] source note
        • window: 3 at.%; 4 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: The ceiling moves down as Nb rises (boundary pile-up by 3 at.% O at 30Nb vs 4 at.% at 14Nb) [grade as written: STRONG as observed for two hosts; finer placement between 3 and 3.5 at.% at 14Nb is NONE (no level in between other than 3.5); basis: J1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: Mechanism: less Ti/Zr-rich short-range order → fewer OOCs → lower O solubility and less ductilisation [grade as written: WEAK (STEM contrast, DFT on 96-atom cells, a fitted internal-friction decomposition); basis: J1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: In a two-phase host (Ti–30Zr–10Nb), any added O cuts ductility [grade as written: STRONG as stated (curves in supplement unseen); cause (suppressed martensite/twinning) WEAK, stated as "might"; basis: J1] source note
        • window: 9.2%; 15.1–18.6%; 1.8 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: Hf-bearing Zr8Hf4Ti3Nb3 gains yield (704 → 1000 MPa) and elongation (9.2% → 15.1–18.6%) up to 1.8 at.% O [grade as written: STRONG as measured (homogenized); basis: W1] source note
        • window: 0.5 at.%; 17.4%; 6.2% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O; ordered oxygen complexes) / other
          • effect: Hf-bearing Zr8Hf6TiNb3 loses ductility at 0.5 at.% O (17.4% → 6.2%) via ω [grade as written: STRONG as measured; ω as the cause WEAK-to-STRONG (observed precipitates, causal link asserted); basis: W1] source note

Ti25Zr35Nb20Hf5Ta15 / NbTiZr refractory HEA

11 checked rows

  • host: Ti25Zr35Nb20Hf5Ta15 / NbTiZr refractory HEA
    • site: interstitial (as the CSV writes it)
      • added: O (interstitial)
        • window: 2 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: 2 at.% O (nominal) Ti25Zr35Nb20Hf5Ta15 is single disordered bcc as cast [grade as written: STRONG as observed (XRD, SAED, BF-TEM); basis: I1] source note
        • window: 2 at.% WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: The oxygen-doped alloy actually holds 2 at.% O [grade as written: WEAK — set by the TiO₂/Ti batch ratio; no gas-fusion or atom-probe oxygen number; the 0.002 Å lattice shift is between rule-of-mixtures values (§3); basis: I1] source note
        • window: ≈37% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Hardness 321 → 440 HV with oxygen (≈37%) [grade as written: STRONG as measured (one pair of castings, ten indents each); basis: I1] source note
        • window: 35% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: 1240 ± 50 MPa compressive yield, no fracture to 35% strain [grade as written: STRONG as measured; strain values relative only; basis: I1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Oxygen raises compressive yield in this alloy [grade as written: NONE in I1 (base-alloy yield not measured); the size of the effect rests on Lei et al. as restated, a different alloy; basis: I1] source note
        • window: 2 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: 2 at.% O alloy forms hcp (Zr, Hf-rich) and a second bcc between 600 and 1000 °C [grade as written: STRONG as observed; that oxygen causes it NONE — CALPHAD for the oxygen-free base alloy predicts both; basis: I1] source note
        • window: ~2 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Below ~2 at.% O, NbTiZr shows negligible metal–metal ordering; above, clustering rises fast [grade as written: STRONG as computed (cluster-expansion MC); experiment matches only at 6.7 at.%; basis: B1] source note
        • window: 6.7 at.%; 13.9 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: NbTiZr base metal at 6.7 at.% O is still bcc, with O–Zr-rich nanodomains (13.9 at.% O) and 10.1–12.1 GPa (3.7× O-free) [grade as written: STRONG as measured (APT, diffraction, nanoindentation; one alloy, one temperature); basis: B1] source note
        • window: ~8–10 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Single-phase ceiling ~8–10 at.% O (spinodal) at 1050 °C [grade as written: STRONG as computed; 6.7 at.% as the measured solubility limit WEAK (an atom-probe bulk value at the interface, set by diffusion, not by an equilibrium dose series); basis: B1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: The O-induced hierarchy keeps NbTiZr tough [grade as written: WEAK — no cracks at indents; nanoindentation is not a ductility test; basis: B1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (interstitial O) / other
          • effect: Oxygen alone drives the phase separations; nitrogen's part [grade as written: WEAK (authors: oxygen "provides the necessary driving force alone"; but they also invoke O+N synergy for hardness); basis: B1] source note

TiVNbTa refractory HEA

5 checked rows

  • host: TiVNbTa refractory HEA
    • site: interstitial (as the CSV writes it)
      • added: O, N (interstitial)
        • window: ~16% STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (interstitial scavenging, age softening)
          • effect: TiVNbTa hardness falls with ageing time at 700 °C, ~16% by 40 days (5.05 → 4.22 GPa) [grade as written: STRONG as measured (one alloy, one temperature, nanoindentation only); basis: L1] source note
        • window: .% STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (interstitial scavenging, age softening)
          • effect: O- and N-rich metallic α-Ti forms, boundaries first, then inside grains (~3 vol.%), with ~3 μm particle-free zones [grade as written: STRONG as observed (STEM, 3D FIB/SEM, APT, EELS, TKD); basis: L1] source note
        • window: ~0.6 at.% STRONG
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (interstitial scavenging, age softening)
          • effect: Matrix C+N+O falls from ~1.2 to ~0.6 at.% between 1 and 40 days [grade as written: STRONG as measured, but few atom-probe tips and the supporting table is in an unseen supplement; basis: L1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (interstitial scavenging, age softening)
          • effect: Trace oxygen is what makes α-Ti stable at 700 °C in this alloy [grade as written: WEAK — a CALPHAD calculation that agrees with the observation; nitrogen's role only "may"; basis: L1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: precipitation / other (interstitial scavenging, age softening)
          • effect: Softening is caused by draining the solution, not by the particles [grade as written: WEAK as a mechanism — supported by an Orowan estimate (particles ≈ 5% of hardness) and by δ tracking hardness; no test with interstitial-free material, no separate O vs N effect; basis: L1] source note

bcc refractory HEAs (MoNbTaW, NbTaTiV, CrMoNbV, etc.)

9 checked rows

  • host: bcc refractory HEAs (MoNbTaW, NbTaTiV, CrMoNbV, etc.)
    • site: no single host: concentrated / multi-principal
      • added: concentrated multi-principal
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: For edge dislocations in bcc HEAs the strong/weak question is answered as in fcc: average matrix, every atom a "solute", collective by construction [grade as written: STRONG (as the model's construction and stated scope); basis: M1 §2; L1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: That edge theory reproduces measured strengths vs temperature for MoNbTaW / MoNbTaVW and, with impurities accounted for, NbTaTiV and CrMoNbV [grade as written: STRONG as reported (no fitted parameters; predictions below experiment, attributed to Hall–Petch, solute–solute interactions, impurities; 900–1300 K plateau not predicted); basis: M1 §4; L1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: Edge-dominated deformation is observed in NbTaTiV and CrMoNbV at 293 K and 1173 K [grade as written: STRONG for those two alloys (ND q-parameters and STEM counts; CrMoNbV ND less reliable at the lowest strain, per L1); basis: L1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: Edge control of MoNbTaW high-T strength [grade as written: WEAK (contested): M1's edge theory fits experiment, but Y1's MD in MoNbTaW finds edges 11–20× more mobile than screws (short 15 nm lines; authors disclaim a strength prediction). Contradicting data, so counted; basis: M1; Y1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: Discrete locks re-appear on screws: cross-kinks and jogs pin the line, and are easier to form in concentrated alloys [grade as written: STRONG as simulated (C1 CoFeNiTi; Y1 MoNbTaW, two different potentials); the "easier in concentrated alloys" expectation is Y1's reading of M2; basis: C1; Y1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: Those screw locks lose effect at high temperature (vacancies defeat jog / cross-kink strength), handing control to edges [grade as written: WEAK — stated by M1 and L1 (same group) as mechanism / expectation; not tested in an opened source; basis: M1; L1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: Screw trapping sites are specific local chemistries (Ti around cross-kinks in CoFeNiTi) [grade as written: STRONG as simulated (one model EAM potential); parallels U1's Co–Cr pins in fcc Cantor (Oct 20); basis: C1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: A bcc concentrated alloy is technically weak-pinning for screws [grade as written: WEAK — Z1's single estimate for the CoFeNiTi model alloy (Lp ≈ 7ξ, from Rao et al.'s 0 K data, not opened); basis: Z1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (edge/screw theory)
          • effect: An opened source settles the TaNbHfZrTi borderline (e.g. a screw-specific pinning length, or a screw vs edge split) [grade as written: NONE; basis: Z1's estimate lumps the total solute strength with Cantor-like line energy; M1 restates mixed edge/screw evidence for TiZrHfNbTa; no opened source computes more] source note

dilute substitutional alloys (Al-X, Mg-Al, etc.)

5 checked rows

  • host: dilute substitutional alloys (Al-X, Mg-Al, etc.)
    • site: substitutional (as the CSV writes it)
      • added: dilute substitutional solutes
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (Fleischer/Labusch theory)
          • effect: The independent-obstacle (one solute, one pin) regime "rarely applies" for moderate binding [grade as written: STRONG; basis: V1 wording; physical reason stated (single-solute barrier ~100–200 meV, T◦F ~100–200 K)] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (Fleischer/Labusch theory)
          • effect: Collective c^(2/3) is seen experimentally [grade as written: STRONG (restated); basis: Kratochvíl & Neradová via V1; V1 Table 1 fits to four dilute fcc binaries; "clusters" patch for Friedel better read as Labusch (V1)] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (Fleischer/Labusch theory)
          • effect: The corpus's √c law (Yasi et al.) is a 0 K trend model for ranking solutes [grade as written: STRONG; basis: V1's description of [39]; Mg–Al basal in the c_trans < 10⁻⁴ list] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (Fleischer/Labusch theory)
          • effect: Over-concentration softening inside an fcc random solid solution [grade as written: NONE (still); basis: Nothing in V1; c^(2/3) has no ceiling in the theory; softening mentioned only for high-Peierls (bcc) materials, outside the model] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (Fleischer/Labusch theory)
          • effect: The Al–Fe ppm failure is a strong-pinning (sub-crossover) effect [grade as written: NONE — not claimed by the source; basis: V1 gives no reason; see OQ2] source note

fcc/bcc concentrated alloys (Co-Cr-Fe-Mn-Ni-V family)

5 checked rows

  • host: fcc/bcc concentrated alloys (Co-Cr-Fe-Mn-Ni-V family)
    • site: substitutional (as the CSV writes it)
      • added: substitutional solutes (misfit volume)
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: The misfit volume (the number the strength theory uses) is host-relative [grade as written: STRONG; basis: By definition (P1, P2: Vₙ − V_alloy); V's misfit is large in both fcc and bcc in opposite directions (P2); "must be calculated in the alloy itself" (P2)] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: The apparent volume carries within a family of similar metals in one structure [grade as written: STRONG; basis: Ni and Cr in NiCoCr ≈ Ni₂Co / Ni₂Cr (P1); one fcc table used across the Co–Cr–Fe–Mn–Ni–V family (P2); Vegard within 0.3–9 % for most elements in two first-principles checks (P3, P4)] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: The apparent volume carries roughly across crystal structure for the same element [grade as written: WEAK as a general claim (holds for V and Cr, the only two elements checked); basis: V 13.8–13.914 fcc vs 14.020 bcc; Cr 12.27 fcc vs 12.321 bcc (P2 tables, mixed sources)] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: The apparent volume is a constant of the element across concentration, electronic state and arbitrary hosts [grade as written: WEAK (contradicted); basis: V 12.20 dilute vs 13.8 at one-third (P2); Co −0.3 ų with magnetism (P1); Pd and Ni ~10–14 % misfit errors under Vegard (P3); Mo 24 % (P4); spreads of 20–39 % for Cu, Mg, Ag, Ti, Al across binary hosts (P5, my arithmetic); Zen's-law sign predicted no better than 60 % (P5)] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: The element's own size sets its local misfit in 3d concentrated alloys [grade as written: NONE there; basis: P6: driven by charge transfer, ordering opposite to pure-element size; P6 scopes this to small size differences] source note

fcc/bcc concentrated alloys (Ni-Co-Fe-Cr-Mn family etc.)

8 checked rows

  • host: fcc/bcc concentrated alloys (Ni-Co-Fe-Cr-Mn family etc.)
    • site: no single host: concentrated / multi-principal
      • added: concentrated multi-principal
        • window: 100% STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: In the average-matrix theory the dilute "√c or c^(2/3)?" question does not arise in its old form: there is no host, every element is a "solute", total solute concentration is 100%, and strength is collective (Labusch-type) by construction [grade as written: STRONG (as the model's construction and stated scope); basis: H1 abstract, §2, §3.3; V1 §3.1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: That construction predicts measured fcc HEA strengths at 293 K [grade as written: STRONG as reported by H1 (Ni-Co-Fe-Cr-Mn family; no fitted parameters); low-T under-prediction at 77 K noted by H1 itself; basis: H1 §6] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: Cantor is technically in the weak (collective) regime [grade as written: STRONG — two groups by different routes (H1 builds it in and validates; Z1 estimates Lp > 9ξ) — but Z1's estimate uses rough line-energy and spacing guesses; basis: Z1 §4; H1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: bcc refractory HEAs are safely weak-pinning [grade as written: WEAK — Z1: TaNbHfZrTi "at the borderline" (Lp ≈ 5ξ, exactly where their own transition sits); basis: Z1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: Localized pinning points exist in a fully random Cantor alloy (simulation), centred on Co with Cr-enriched surroundings, and only the strong ones survive at 300 K [grade as written: STRONG as simulated (one MEAM potential for the Cantor family; the authors also test EAM-based HEAs); TEM consistent (wavy, jerky lines; no detected clustering); basis: U1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV WEAK
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: Those localized pins control macroscopic yield strength (i.e. HEAs are strong-pinning in Z1's technical sense) [grade as written: WEAK — U1 disclaims a strengthening model; "strong pinning" in U1 is used descriptively (V-shaped pinned spots), and U1 does not compute Z1's pinning length; basis: U1, Z1] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV NONE
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: An opened source says the collective account is overturned for fcc HEAs [grade as written: NONE; basis: No opened source says so; H1 argues long lines bow around rare strong regions] source note
        • window: window not given in CSV STRONG
          • mechanism: solid-solution strengthening (theory)
          • effect: More components ≠ more strength [grade as written: STRONG for H1's statement (strength not set by N, not maximal at equiatomic); STRONG as simulated for U1's Fe/Mn dilution of strong pins and CoCr > CoCrNi pinning; as a measured strength trend beyond U1's cited hardness/yield ordering — WEAK; basis: H1 §7; U1] source note

Move demo: substitutional ↔ interstitial (illustration only)

  • host lattice
    • substitutional site (replaces a host atom)
      • solute X
    • interstitial site (sits in a gap)

    Without JavaScript this stays a static drawing.

    Data: export/host-systems.csv (checked rows only). Family grouping (solid-solution / precipitation / other) is by the first words of mechanism_type.