No joint field · Bridge A = SPECULATIVE pedagogy

Labels: SOURCED HYPOTHESIS SPECULATIVE OPEN NONE (REAL = same-domain materials or linguistics, shown like SOURCED)

Path E · Materials scout (does a solute's size number travel?)

Misfit-volume portability: does an element bring its own size number from host to host? — materials scout,

What’s claimed and how well supported

Labels on this page
STRONG ×7 WEAK ×5 SPECULATIVE ×7 NONE ×1
Strongest label used
STRONG
Main caveat (quoted)
The Bridge A section and the Navajo remark come after the materials and are ◆ SPECULATIVE.

Counted automatically from the labels printed on this page. Counts are a reading aid, not a grade of the page.

Terms on this page (6), plain-language definitions
Solute
Intentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition).
Dopant
Intentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase.
Host (matrix)
Majority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material.
BCC
Body-centered cubic — Fe/steel common; plasticity more temperature-sensitive.
Solid solution
Solute atoms dissolved into the host lattice (substitutional or interstitial) without a separate precipitate phase.
Valency (ling.)
Arity: how many actants a predicate takes; formal vs semantic valency can diverge.

Definitions quoted from the Chem for linguists primer glossary.

Date: 2026-10-16 PT (weekday research push, evening)
Status: Materials scout. The metallurgy is same-domain description from the sources opened below (REAL inside physical metallurgy). The grades and the arithmetic on the sources' tables are my analysis. The Bridge A section and the Navajo remark come after the materials and are SPECULATIVE. Not a correlate. Not a joint field.
Audience: Grant (syntax/semantics; less chemistry). End goal: designing new metal alloys. Direct follow-up to Solute strengthening: host part vs element part (its open question 3).
Vocabulary lock kept: percent-level additions are solutesIntentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition). / alloying additions, not dopantsIntentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase. (Doping vs alloying vocabulary).
Does not: claim that a solute, an atomic volume or a lattice site is an argument, operator, feature bundle or theta role; supply a chemical stand-in for a theta role; invent numbers or quotes; revise Bridge A; run the six-point ranking-edge spec.

Why this note. Last night's note found that the modern elastic theory of solute strengthening splits its inputs cleanly — the hostMajority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material. (or averaged alloy) gives lattice size, elastic constants, line tension and core structure; each solute gives a concentration and a misfit volume ΔVₙ. Its first counter-case was that the solute's number "reflects the average local atomic environment around the element" (Yin et al. 2020), so I wrote "The filler is not a portable feature bundle." Its open question 3 asked how far that is true: Yin et al. found Ni's apparent volume in NiCoCr close to Ni's in Ni₂Co and Ni₂Cr. Tonight's job: open sources that put one element's volume number into several hosts and see how far it carries. This is the cleanest materials test so far of "does the element bring a fixed feature, or is its number set by the host?"

The case, in plain words. Every atom in a metal takes up some room. If you add atoms of element X to a host and measure how the crystal's volume per atom changes, you can work out how much room X seems to take up in that host — its apparent volume Vₙ. Its misfit volume is how far that is from the average room per atom in the alloy: ΔVₙ = Vₙ − V_alloy (the Vegard form; the exact form uses slopes). The misfit is what strengthens the metal (it enters squared, last night's §2.1). So there are two numbers to test for portability: the apparent volume (could be the element's own) and the misfit (element minus host average, so it cannot be fully the element's own). The simplest guess that the element's volume carries unchanged is Vegard's law (in volume form, Zen's law): the alloy's volume per atom is just the concentration-weighted average of the elements' own volumes.

What is new (one sentence). The sources give a two-layer answer: within a family of similar metals in one crystal structure, an element's apparent volume carries from alloy to alloy well enough that one table per family is used for strength prediction (Ni and Cr in NiCoCr ≈ in Ni₂Co / Ni₂Cr; first-principles misfits in Mo–Nb–Ta–V–W closely follow Vegard's law with elemental volumes, in P4's words) — STRONG within a family — but it shifts with concentration (V: 12.20 ų dilute in Ni vs 13.8 ų in Ni₂V), with magnetism (Co ~0.3 ų lower in NiCoCr), and widely across unrelated binary hosts (my arithmetic on the King/Lubarda-derived table in Landa et al.: Cu's apparent volume runs 9.60–14.17 ų over six hosts) — WEAK as a general element constant — while the misfit is host-relative by construction (V has a large misfit in both fcc and bcc alloys, in opposite directions: "large in the fcc alloys and small in the bcc alloys") — STRONG; so last night's sentence "the filler is not a portable feature bundle" needs a refinement: the apparent volume is a partly portable element number, the misfit is not.


1. Sources

1.1 Opened this run

Key Source How read Used for
P1 Yin, Yoshida, Tsuji & Curtin 2020, "Yield strength and misfit volumes of NiCoCr and implications for short-range-order," Nat. Commun. 11: 2507 Europe PMC full-text XML (PMC7237450), TeX kept; same file as S2 of last night's note, re-read for the apparent-volume passages Apparent volume defined; Ni, Cr, Co in NiCoCr vs Ni₂Co / Ni₂Cr; Co magnetism; DFT misses Cr
P2 Yin, Maresca & Curtin 2020, "Vanadium is an optimal element for strengthening in both fcc and bcc high-entropy alloys," Acta Mater. 188: 486 Submitted preprint (EPFL Infoscience bitstream Acta_Vanadium_submit.pdf, CC BY-NC-SA; curl, HTTP 200, no challenge served); pdftotext; tables also from -layout Vegard form; "must be calculated in the alloy itself"; fcc apparent-volume table (restating Varvenne et al. 2016) and bcc table; V dilute vs Ni₂V vs elemental; V large in fcc, small in bcc
P3 Yin & Curtin 2019, "First-principles-based prediction of yield strength in the RhIrPdPtNiCu high-entropy alloy," npj Comput. Mater. 5: 14 nature.com open-access PDF; pdftotext (formulas garbled, not quoted) Vegard (elemental volumes) vs direct first-principles misfits, element by element (their Table 2)
P4 Maresca & Curtin, "Mechanistic Origin of High Strength in Refractory BCCBody-centered cubic — Fe/steel common; plasticity more temperature-sensitive. High Entropy Alloys up to 1900K," arXiv:1901.02100v3 (2019; journal version Acta Mater. 182 (2020) 235 not checked) arXiv PDF; text layer; Table 2 from -layout Vegard vs first-principles misfits in MoNbTaVW and MoNbTaW
P5 Landa, Klepeis, Rudd, Caspersen & Young, "Analytic binary alloy volume-concentration relations and the deviation from Zens law," arXiv:2004.12966 (LLNL) | arXiv PDF; text layer; Tables 2–3 from-layout`. Restates King 1966 volume size factors and Lubarda's apparent radii (both primary sources not opened) Zen's law unreliable; apparent solute size "when resolved in the solvent matrix"; real vs apparent volumes in 22 binaries (cross-host test)
P6 Oh et al. 2019, "Engineering atomic-level complexity in high-entropy and complex concentrated alloys," Nat. Commun. 10: 2090 Europe PMC full-text XML (PMC6504951); supplementary tables not opened In 3d alloys the local misfit is driven by charge transfer, not by the elements' own sizes; predicted from an electronegativity difference

Verbatim passages: excerpts-verbatim.md (not published here) (cut programmatically by make_excerpts.py from the saved text files); table blocks: tables-verbatim.md (not published here) (cut programmatically from the -layout files). Quote fragments in this note machine-checked with check_quotes.py.

1.2 Not opened (do not treat as read)

  • Leyson & Curtin 2013, Phil. Mag. 93: 2428 (for OQ1): EPFL Infoscience record page served a "verify that you're not a robot" JavaScript check to WebFetch; Taylor & Francis abstract page timed out in WebFetch and returned a Cloudflare "Just a moment" page (HTTP 403) to one curl. Not routed around. A search-result copy of the abstract was seen with its numbers stripped out; not used.
  • King 1966, "Quantitative size-factors for metallic solid solutionsSolute atoms dissolved into the host lattice (substitutional or interstitial) without a separate precipitate phase.," J. Mater. Sci. 1: 79, and Lubarda 2003 (apparent Wigner–Seitz radii): not opened; their values enter only as restated in P5's Tables 2–3.
  • Varvenne, Luque & Curtin 2016, Acta Mater. 118: 164: not opened; its fcc apparent-volume table enters only as restated in P2's Table 1.
  • Oh et al. 2019 Supplementary Table 2 (element radii and electronegativities): not opened.
  • The 2026 TMS abstract "Hume-Rothery and Atomic Misfits" (Curtin) — announces a test of Vegard's law for atomic volumes across several fcc and bcc alloy families; seen as a search result only, no paper opened; not used as evidence.
  • Simmons & Wang 1971, Couzinie et al. 2015, Petry et al. 1991 (sources of P2's bcc table), Jacob et al. (P5 ref. 49): not opened.

2. Sourced materials

2.1 What apparent volume and misfit volume are, and which one could be portable

  • Definition (P1). "For simplicity in comparisons here, we consider the apparent atomic volume for each element in the alloy defined as" V_alloy + ΔVₙ (TeX in the XML). So apparent volume = alloy average + misfit; misfit = apparent volume − alloy average.
  • The Vegard shortcut (P2). "A widely-used approximation is Veg- 154 P ard’s law Valloy = n cn Vn, leading to misfit volumes 181 ∆Vn = Vn − Valloy where Vn is the apparent volume of 182 type-n element in the given crystal structure." (Text layer with the preprint's line numbers interleaved; it reads V_alloy = Σₙ cₙVₙ and ΔVₙ = Vₙ − V_alloy.) Note the phrase "in the given crystal structure": even in the shortcut, the element's number is per structure, not per element.
  • Why misfits rather than moduli (P2). "The theory demonstrates that the solute misfit volumes control strengthening because the alloy elastic moduli vary more slowly with composition."
  • Not a local volume (P2). "apparent volume of a solute is not 187 the local Voronoi-volume around the solute in the lat- 188 tice. The misfit volume involves distortions that extend 189 to near-neighbor atoms and beyond".
  • Measure it where you use it (P2). "Second, the misfit volume of a solute must be calculated in the alloy itself, or in an appropriate surrogate alloy having the same solute concentration. A misfit volume computed in a surrogate alloy in the dilute solute limit may be quite inaccurate because Vegard’s law does not always hold with sufficient accuracy."
  • Older binary language (P5). Lubarda used "an apparent size of the solute atom when resolved in the solvent matrix", an apparent radius "introduced to approximately account for the electronic interactions between the outermost quantum shells of the solute and solvent atoms." King "presented numerical values of ωi for 469 metallic solid solutions" (ω = volume size factor, the initial slope of volume with solute content, relative to the solvent).

So the misfit is host-relative by definition. The open question is the apparent volume.

2.2 Within one family: the apparent volume carries (P1, P2, P3, P4)

Cantor family, fcc, measured (P1). Abstract: precise lattice constants give "an accurate determination of the Ni, Co, and Cr misfit/apparent volumes, which generally agree with those found for random Ni2Co and Ni2Cr binary alloys." In detail: "The apparent volume of Ni in NiCoCr as measured here is very close to those found for Ni in both Ni2Co and Ni2Cr. The apparent volume for Cr in NiCoCr as measured here is also very close to that found for Ni2Cr." And: "Experiments show that the alloy atomic volume and apparent volumes of Ni and Cr are nearly the same as in Ni2Cr."

One table for the whole family (P2, restating Varvenne et al. 2016). P2's Table 1 lists one fcc apparent volume per element — Cr 12.27, Mn 12.60, Fe 12.09, Co 11.12, Ni 10.94 ų — "deduced from experiments on Ni, NiCo, Ni-Cr, and Ni-Fe binary alloys, and from Mn additions to various Co-Cr-Fe-Ni alloys" (table caption; block in tables-verbatim.md (not published here)), and uses that one table with Vegard's law to predict strengths across the Co–Cr–Fe–Mn–Ni–V family ("We use the analytic model of Eqs. 1 and 2 with Vegard’s law, the atomic volumes in Table 1, and the experimental polycrystalline isotropic elastic constants."). One check from that use: "NiCo has near-zero misfit and near-zero strength relative to pure Ni." (P2 reports agreement with measured strengths for several alloys; I have not re-checked those strength numbers here.) The Cr value in P1, measured in Ni₂Cr/NiCoCr, is "12.30 Å3" — close to the table's 12.27 (my comparison; two numbers from the same research group).

Noble-metal fcc, first-principles (P3). Vegard's law works from the elements' own volumes: "Then only the lattice constants and elastic constants of the elemental metals are needed in the crystal structure of the HEA." Against direct first-principles misfits in RhIrPdPtNiCu (P3 Table 2): Rh 0.253 vs 0.259, Ir 0.767 vs 0.799, Ni −2.581 vs −2.841, Pd 1.412 vs 1.605, Pt 1.835 vs 1.893, Cu −1.686 vs −1.715 ų (direct vs Vegard). My arithmetic: Vegard's misfit is off by 1.7–4.2 % for Rh, Ir, Pt, Cu and by about 10 % (Ni) and 14 % (Pd). Net: "Vegard’s law yields δ = 4.193%. This is ~8% larger than the direct DFT result of δ = 3.873% on the actual random alloy". P3's own verdict on the whole shortcut (volumes plus rule-of-mixtures moduli): "The approximate approach above is thus of limited value for quantitative prediction in this family of alloys." — though they add that it "may be too high mainly due to the moduli estimates", i.e. the volume part was the better half.

Refractory bcc, first-principles (P4). "First-principles DFT is used to compute the solute misfit volumes in the true random MoNbTaW and MoNbTaVW alloys, as shown in Table 2." The next sentence says the misfit volumes closely follow Vegard's law with Vₙ "the elemental BCC atomic volumes" (the text layer splits that verb across a line with a stray summation sign, so it is not quoted). Then: "The DFT-computed atomic volumes differ slightly from the experimental values, however. So, we use Vegard’s law based on the experimental atomic volumes of the alloy elements which yields values of V̄ in good agreement with experiment." P4 Table 2, MoNbTaVW (DFT vs Vegard): Mo −0.824 vs −0.628, Nb 1.848 vs 1.713, Ta 1.882 vs 1.877, V −2.380 vs −2.484, W −0.526 vs −0.478 ų. My arithmetic: Ta 0.3 %, V 4.4 %, Nb 7.3 %, W 9.1 %, Mo 24 %. In MoNbTaW (no V) all four are within 3.4 %. A different model does worse: "the misfit volumes computed using the Zhou et al. EAM potentials differ somewhat from the DFT values (see Table 2) and so are not used."

One analysis point (mine). A misfit is a small difference between two big numbers. In P3, Vegard's Pd error is 0.193 ų — about 14 % of Pd's misfit, but only about 1 % of an atomic volume of order 15 ų (the fcc and bcc tables in P2 and the real volumes in P5 put metal atomic volumes at roughly 11–23 ų). So the apparent volume can carry to about 1 % while the misfit carries only to about 14 %, at once. Portability of the element's volume is much better than portability of the strengthening number built from it.

2.3 Concentration: the same element in the same host, different amount (P2)

Vanadium in nickel-rich fcc: - Elemental fcc V (first-principles): 13.914 ų (P2 Table 1). - V in Ni₂V (one-third V; first-principles): "To remain consistent with the apparent volume of Ni (10.94 Å3 ), the corresponding apparent volume of V is determined as 13.8 Å3, in good agreement with the elemental fcc V volume." - V dilute in Ni: "Other very recent literature [22] reports the apparent volume of V as 12.23 Å3. However, this value was computed for V in Ni in the dilute limit (one V atom in a large cell). Our own calculations yielding 12.20 Å3 confirm this dilute-limit value, but it differs significantly from the value at more appropriate concentrations, e.g. 13.8 Å3 as computed here from Ni2 V."

My arithmetic: 13.8 − 12.20 = 1.6 ų, about 12 % of V's apparent volume, and nearly as large as V's whole misfit in Ni₂V (ΔV_V = 1.920 ų, P2). So the same element in the same host gives a different volume number at different concentrations. This is contradicting data for "the element brings one fixed number", inside the concentration window itself.

Also from P2: the wrong definition gives a third number — "Applying the incorrect Voronoi method to Ni2 V would yield an apparent V volume of 11.8 Å3." (definition issue, not a host effect; recorded so the 11.8 is not confused with the others).

2.4 Electronic state of the element changes its number (P1)

  • Co: "The apparent volume for Co in NiCoCr is slightly lower by ~0.3 Å3 than that found in Ni2Co; this is not unexpected due to the magnetic interactions between Co and Cr and the strong dependence of Co atomic volume on the Co magnetic moment". Later the same paper says "This rationalizes why the apparent Co volume in NiCoCr is significantly smaller than that in Co and Ni2Co, in both experiments and DFT." (Both wordings, "slightly" and "significantly", are in P1.)
  • Cr, first-principles: "In these two nonmagnetic cases, the apparent volumes of Cr are close (~11.74 Å3) and also close to nonmagnetic VASP-SQS values (~11.63 Å3, not shown in Fig. 4). All of these values remain, however, far below the experimental value (12.30 Å3)." So even the computed element number depends on the electronic (magnetic) state assumed.

2.5 Across crystal structure: the volume roughly carries, the misfit flips (P2)

  • P2's abstract: "The origin of Vanadium’s special role is its atomic volume: large in the fcc alloys and small in the bcc alloys, and thus having a large misfit volume in both crystalline structures."
  • The numbers (P2 Tables 1–2): V 13.8–13.914 ų in fcc; 14.020 ų in bcc (elemental, experimental). Cr 12.27 ų in fcc (from Ni–Cr), 12.321 ų in bcc (elemental). My comparison: V's and Cr's own numbers differ by roughly 1 % or less between the two structures.
  • What changes is the company: fcc partners are Ni, Co, Fe, Mn (10.94–12.60 ų), bcc partners Mo, W, Nb, Ta, Ti, Hf, Zr (15.524–23.02 ų; only bcc Cr, 12.321 ų, is smaller than V). Same element volume, opposite-sign misfit. "Here, V stands out as the secondsmallest element, with only Cr being smaller. However, Cr is smaller than V in both fcc and bcc and so although Cr can be potent for bcc alloys it is not nearly as effective as V in fcc alloys (see Fig. 1)." (The text layer joins "second-smallest" across a line break.) Conclusion of P2: "uniqueness of V then follows from its atomic volume in fcc and bcc crystals: larger in fcc and smaller in bcc than other HEA alloying elements, creating large misfit volume and high strengthening in both fcc and bcc alloys."

This is the cleanest case tonight: the element's volume is (roughly) its own; whether that volume is big or small is set by the host.

2.6 Across unrelated binary hosts: King's size factors, as restated (P5)

  • Zen's law is not reliable in general: "Models exist to predict the deviation from Zens law; however, they are not sufficiently reliable. Even the probability to predict the sign of the deviation from Zens law does not exceed 60 %." P5's conclusion reports (from Jacob et al., not opened) that "both Vegard’s and Zen`s laws should be downgraded to an approximation which is valid in specific conditions."
  • P5's Table 3 gives each element's real volume and its apparent volume as a dilute solute in the other element, for 22 binaries (derived from King's measured initial slopes through Lubarda's elastic-inclusion model, which also uses both metals' moduli). Several elements appear as the solute in more than one host, which allows a direct portability test. My arithmetic on Table 3 (apparent volume of the element as dilute solute; real volume in brackets):
Element (real Ω, ų) Host → apparent volume (ų) Range; spread as % of real
Cu (11.8072) Al 11.8247; Ni 11.8510; Au 12.4972; Ag 13.0147; Fe 14.1683; Zn 9.5991 9.60–14.17; 38.7 %
Mg (23.2396) Al 27.4032; Cd 21.6319; Ag 18.9916 18.99–27.40; 36.2 %
Ag (17.0578) Al 16.6193; Au 16.8408; Cu 18.4090; Mg 13.9318 13.93–18.41; 26.2 %
Ti (17.6542) Zr 18.6324; Al 14.4677 14.47–18.63; 23.6 %
Al (16.6036) Mg 17.2016; Ag 15.3642; Cu 15.0820; Mn 14.5684; Zn 14.2961; Ti 13.8034 13.80–17.20; 20.5 %
Fe (11.7771) Cu 12.3236; Cr 11.7664; Co 11.4817; V 11.4252 11.43–12.32; 7.6 %
Zn (15.2123) Al 15.6559; Cu 14.6320 6.7 %
Au (16.9618) Cu 17.8913; Ag 16.7868 6.5 %
Cr (12.0064) Fe 12.3105; W 11.5458 6.4 %

Reading (mine): elements that sit among similar transition-metal or noble-metal partners (Fe among Co, Cr, V; Cr; Au; Zn) carry their volume to within about 6–8 %; elements moved between very different hosts (Cu into Zn or Fe; Mg into Al or Ag; Ti into Al) do not, with spreads of 20–39 %. Caveats: several of these hosts dissolve very little of the solute, so the initial slope comes from a short range; the apparent volumes are model-derived; and P5 itself records one family where "the apparent volume theory" fails ("Only if one uses the real volumes instead of apparent volumes, the experimental results can be reproduced", Si–Ge, which P5 links to "Both pure Ge and Si are not metals").

2.7 Electronic counter-case: the local misfit tracks charge transfer, not the element's size (P6)

  • "The atomic-level pressure originates from the misfit of an element with its surroundings in terms of its atomic size, electronic state and charge transfer (Supplementary Fig. 1). In conventional dilute alloys, most solutes are surrounded by solvent atoms, with little interaction among solutes (Fig. 1a). Thus, previous approaches for treating the bonding and misfit in dilute alloys assume a fixed atomic-level pressure for a solute element12,13. On the other hand, the local atomic environment in CCAs is chemically complex (Fig. 1a)14,15; thus the atomic-level pressure fluctuates depending on the specific local environment."
  • "Furthermore, the order of atomic-level pressure of each element (Cr<Mn<Fe<Co<Ni) is opposite to the order of atomic sizes of the same elements in pure state (Cr>Mn>Fe>Co>Ni)" … "This result is a clear indication that the atomic-level pressure (and hence, the misfit volume) of 3d CCAs is driven by the charge transfer, not by the atomic size difference17."
  • Scope limit, stated by P6: "The main reason why the charge transfer is the dominant factor for the atomic-level pressure in the 3d CCAs is that the differences in the atomic sizes among the elements considered here are relatively small."
  • The element-level predictor P6 proposes is itself a difference: the average charge transfer "can be simply approximated by the local electronegativity difference" χ_X − χ_element, "where χX is the electronegativity of element X (Supplementary Table 2), and χelement is the weighted average electronegativity over the element31".

Note (mine): P6's quantity is a computed atomic-level pressure, not the apparent volume of P1/P2. I have not reconciled P6's pressure ordering with P1/P2's measured apparent volumes (Cr has the largest positive misfit in NiCoCr per P1); that needs P6's supplementary material and is left as an open question. What P6 does show is the same two-layer shape as §2.5: a tabulated element number (electronegativity χ_X) enters only as a difference from its surroundings.


3. Grading (analysis)

The question. Does the element bring a fixed number (one that would count as a portable feature in Grant's sense), or is its number set by the host?

Claim Grade Basis
The misfit volume (the number the strength theory uses) is host-relative STRONG By definition (P1, P2: Vₙ − V_alloy); V's misfit is large in both fcc and bcc in opposite directions (P2); "must be calculated in the alloy itself" (P2)
The apparent volume carries within a family of similar metals in one structure STRONG Ni and Cr in NiCoCr ≈ Ni₂Co / Ni₂Cr (P1); one fcc table used across the Co–Cr–Fe–Mn–Ni–V family (P2); Vegard within 0.3–9 % for most elements in two first-principles checks (P3, P4)
The apparent volume carries roughly across crystal structure for the same element WEAK as a general claim (holds for V and Cr, the only two elements checked) V 13.8–13.914 fcc vs 14.020 bcc; Cr 12.27 fcc vs 12.321 bcc (P2 tables, mixed sources)
The apparent volume is a constant of the element across concentration, electronic state and arbitrary hosts WEAK (contradicted) V 12.20 dilute vs 13.8 at one-third (P2); Co −0.3 ų with magnetism (P1); Pd and Ni ~10–14 % misfit errors under Vegard (P3); Mo 24 % (P4); spreads of 20–39 % for Cu, Mg, Ag, Ti, Al across binary hosts (P5, my arithmetic); Zen's-law sign predicted no better than 60 % (P5)
The element's own size sets its local misfit in 3d concentrated alloys NONE there P6: driven by charge transfer, ordering opposite to pure-element size; P6 scopes this to small size differences

Correction to last night's note (refinement, flagged here). Solute strengthening: host part vs element part §3 counter-case 1 said "The filler is not a portable feature bundle." Tonight's sources make that too strong as stated. Better: the misfit is not portable (host-relative by construction); the apparent volume is a partly portable element number — portable within a family and roughly across fcc/bcc for V and Cr, not across concentration, magnetic state or very different hosts. The back-pointer at that note's OQ3 records this; the earlier note itself is left as written.

Line-up with the lattice-strain model (from last night's §3), sharpened. In lattice strain the ion brings a tabulated radius rⱼ and the site brings r₀; the penalty uses rⱼ − r₀. Tonight's materials have the same arrangement: the element brings an apparent volume Vₙ (partly portable), the host brings V_alloy, and the strength uses Vₙ − V_alloy. The difference: rⱼ is treated as the ion's own constant (per charge and coordination), while Vₙ is measurably host-, concentration- and magnetism-dependent. Grade of the sharpened parallel: STRONG for the arrangement (element number minus host reference), WEAK for "the element number is a constant", as in the table above.

Counting rule. Per Grant's rule, only contradicting data count against "the element brings a fixed feature": the V concentration shift, Co magnetism, the P3/P4 per-element Vegard errors, the P5 cross-host spreads, and P6's charge-transfer result. Silence (e.g. no source testing V across ten hosts) is not counted.


4. Secondary: Fleischer–Labusch crossover (last night's OQ1) — no progress

Leyson & Curtin 2013 could not be opened (EPFL bot check; Taylor & Francis Cloudflare; §1.2). No other opened source tonight states a crossover concentration. The in-corpus position is unchanged: √c for dilute, isolated obstacles (Yasi et al., last night's S4) and c^(2/3) for collective pinning (last night's §2.4). One related point is sourced tonight: P2's insistence that misfits be computed in the alloy at the working concentration, with V's apparent volume moving 1.6 ų between dilute and one-third (§2.3) — so the solute's input number, not only the scaling law, changes across the concentration range. OQ1 stays open.


SPECULATIVE Cross-domain section. Open after the materials.

5. Bridge A — SPECULATIVE (after the materials)

Bridge A (locked): doping concentration windows and over-doping ↔ valencyArity: how many actants a predicate takes; formal vs semantic valency can diverge., argument saturation and over-arity. What tonight adds, as shape only:

  • The filler's own number moves across the concentration window. V's apparent volume is 12.20 ų dilute and 13.8 ų at one-third in Ni (P2). On the window picture, the solute is not one fixed item counted more or fewer times; what it contributes per atom changes as the window fills. Argument saturation is discrete and does not have this. Lock "continuous wt% ≠ discrete arity" holds.
  • Element number + host reference → a relational value. Both the volume case (Vₙ − V_alloy) and the electronegativity case (χ_X − weighted average, P6) take a tabulated element number and use it only as a difference from the surroundings. On the language side, the nearest shape would be a feature that a word brings with it but that counts only relative to the frame. I know of no sourced linguistic statement that maps onto this, and none is claimed.
  • Same element, opposite role in two structures. V is large among fcc partners and small among bcc partners (P2). Shape only: one filler, the same own value, scored in opposite directions by two hosts. Not a theta role; no stand-in.

Navajo remark ( SPECULATIVE, one paragraph). On Navajo Decoded, a role-bearing pronoun slot is set by the verb and a noun links to it by features; Grant's layered-assignment idea (roles first, noun selection later) is his open hypothesis. Tonight's materials give the most direct test yet of "does the filler bring its own feature?" and the answer is layered: the element brings a number that carries within a family (in favour of a portable filler feature), but the number the outcome actually uses is that feature minus a host reference (the frame decides what the feature is worth), and the element's own number drifts with concentration and electronic state (against a fixed feature bundle). Per the counting rule, the contradicting data are in §3; none of them is about language. No chemical stand-in for a theta role or a feature bundle; not a correlate; Bridge A unrevised; not a joint field.


6. Open questions

  1. Fleischer–Labusch crossover (carried from last night's OQ1). Leyson & Curtin 2013 blocked tonight; still open. → Taken up 2026-10-19 evening in Fleischer–Labusch crossover: when does one solute pin alone?: via the Varvenne, Leyson, Ghazisaeidi & Curtin 2017 overview (pre-print), the zero-T crossover is ~10⁻² but at finite temperature it falls below ~10⁻⁴ (above 78 K for Al–X and Mg–Al, restating Leyson & Curtin 2013), so strong pinning "rarely applies" (STRONG); Leyson & Curtin's own full text still not opened (record metadata-only).
  2. How wide is a family? P2 uses one fcc table for Co–Cr–Fe–Mn–Ni–V; P5's binaries show 20–39 % spreads once hosts differ strongly. Where between those does portability fail? The 2026 Curtin TMS abstract promises a Vegard test across several fcc and bcc alloy families — seen only as a search result; look for the paper.
  3. Concentration dependence of an apparent volume. Is V's 12.20 → 13.8 ų shift typical? A measured (not first-principles) case would help.
  4. P6 vs P1/P2. Reconcile P6's atomic-level pressure ordering (Cr lowest) with the measured apparent volumes (Cr's misfit positive and largest in NiCoCr); needs P6's supplementary tables.
  5. King 1966 and Lubarda 2003 directly. Tonight's cross-host table is P5's restatement; the primaries were not opened.
  6. Process side (carried): nothing opened on how a process puts the solute where it ends up.

7. Separation

SOURCED (inside metallurgy)

Apparent and misfit volume definitions (P1, P2); Ni and Cr in NiCoCr ≈ binaries, Co lower with magnetism, Cr first-principles vs experiment (P1); Vegard form "in the given crystal structure", not Voronoi, "must be calculated in the alloy itself", fcc and bcc apparent-volume tables, V dilute vs Ni₂V vs elemental, V large in fcc and small in bcc (P2); Vegard vs direct first-principles misfits in RhIrPdPtNiCu, δ ~8 % high, "limited value" verdict (P3); Vegard vs first-principles in MoNbTaVW/MoNbTaW, misfits closely following Vegard (P4); Zen's-law unreliability, apparent solute size "resolved in the solvent matrix", King's 469 size factors, real vs apparent volumes in 22 binaries, Si–Ge failure (P5, restating King and Lubarda); charge transfer not size in 3d alloys, electronegativity-difference predictor, scope limited to small size differences (P6).

ANALYSIS (mine, beside the sources)

Per-element Vegard error percentages (P3, P4 tables); the V concentration shift as a percentage; the cross-host table and spreads (P5 Table 3); the volume-portable-to-~1 % / misfit-to-~14 % point; the grades in §3; the refinement of last night's counter-case 1; the sharpened lattice-strain line-up; comparisons across sources (Cr 12.27 vs 12.30 vs 12.321; V fcc vs bcc), which mix reference data and are indicative only.

SPECULATIVE

§5 (Bridge A shapes; Navajo remark). Grant's feature-bundle and layered-assignment ideas remain his open hypotheses.

Not claimed

No chemical correlate. No chemical stand-in for a theta role, a feature bundle or a slot. Not a joint field. Bridge A unrevised. No Fleischer–Labusch crossover value. Nothing from the blocked or unopened sources (Leyson & Curtin; King and Lubarda primaries; Varvenne 2016; P6 supplement; the TMS abstract) used as evidence.


8. Verdict

How portable is one element's misfit volume? The misfit itself is not portable — it is the element's apparent volume minus the host's average, so the same element can be a large misfit in one host and a small (opposite-sign) misfit in another, as V is in fcc vs bcc high-entropy alloys ( STRONG, P2). The element's apparent volume is partly portable: within one family of similar metals in one crystal structure it carries well enough to tabulate once and reuse (Ni and Cr in NiCoCr vs Ni₂Co/Ni₂Cr, P1; Cantor-family table, P2; Vegard within a few percent for most elements in two first-principles checks, P3–P4: STRONG), but it is not a constant of the element: it moves with concentration (V 12.20 → 13.8 ų, P2), with magnetism (Co, P1), and by 20–39 % across very different binary hosts (my arithmetic on P5's table), and in 3d concentrated alloys the local misfit is driven by charge transfer rather than the elements' own sizes (P6) ( WEAK as a general element constant). The materials therefore answer "fixed feature or host-relative number?" with "both, in two layers": an element number that is partly portable, and an outcome-relevant number that is always relative to the host. Last night's "the filler is not a portable feature bundle" is refined accordingly. OQ1 (Fleischer–Labusch crossover) not advanced: the key source was blocked.


v0 — 2026-10-16 PT, evening. Pointers added: corpus-reading-order row; CONCLUSIONS-v1-addendum paragraph; site-content-map (inventory, Path E list, slug, near-ready, Path E page row; solute-strengthening row marked live); back-pointer at solute-strengthening-slot-vs-element OQ3. Speculation flagged. Bridge A lock unrevised. No joint field.

Corpus note: misfit-volume-portability-v0.md. The metallurgy is same-domain description from the sources the note lists as opened; blocked and unopened sources are listed and not used. Percentages computed from the sources' tables are marked as the note's own arithmetic. The grades (STRONG / WEAK / NONE) are analysis, not a declared correlate. The Bridge A section and the Navajo remark come after the materials and are speculative. No chemical stand-in for a theta role or a feature bundle. Bridge A unrevised. Not a joint field.