No joint field · Bridge A = SPECULATIVE pedagogy

Labels: SOURCED HYPOTHESIS SPECULATIVE OPEN NONE (REAL = same-domain materials or linguistics, shown like SOURCED)

Path E · Materials scorecard (Navajo findings)

What survives of the Navajo findings, and what the materials literature offers beside each — materials scout,

What’s claimed and how well supported

Labels on this page
REAL ×1 STRONG ×5 WEAK ×8 SPECULATIVE ×2 NONE ×8
Strongest label used
STRONG
Main caveat (quoted)
Bridge A is not touched.

Counted automatically from the labels printed on this page. Counts are a reading aid, not a grade of the page.

Terms on this page (6), plain-language definitions
Vacancy
Point defect: a missing atom site in the lattice.
Valence (chem.)
Bonding capacity / oxidation-related electron count of an atom in context.
Host (matrix)
Majority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material.
Solute
Intentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition).
Solid solution
Solute atoms dissolved into the host lattice (substitutional or interstitial) without a separate precipitate phase.
Dopant
Intentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase.

Definitions quoted from the Chem for linguists primer glossary.

Date: 2026-10-15 PT (afternoon; Grant: "switch back to investigating physical science and see what new connections come up")
Status: Materials scout with a scorecard. The materials statements are same-domain description from the sources opened below ( REAL inside crystal chemistry, geochemistry and metallurgy). Setting them beside the Navajo findings is analysis, and every grade below is a grade of an analog, not a declared correlate. Navajo statements are quoted as the Navajo Decoded site states them and carry the status that site gives them. Bridge A is not touched.
Audience: Grant (linguistics; less chemistry). End goal: designing new metal alloys.
Does not: declare any chemical correlate; supply a chemical stand-in for a theta role; invent numbers or quotes; claim that a lattice site, a Wyckoff position or an electronegativity scale is a theta role, a feature bundle or a rank; claim the gap is closed; revise Bridge A; merge with the Si-donor, produce-vs-maintain or ranking-edge notes (it cites them).

Why this note. On 2026-10-15 Grant asked to go back to the physical-science side after the Navajo work. The Navajo work has settled on four findings that survived testing (below). This note takes each one to the materials literature, asks for a sourced analog with verbatim text, tries to break each analog with a counter-case from the same literature, grades it STRONG / WEAK / NONE, and says which Navajo findings have no analog at all.

Grades used. STRONG = the sourced materials account has the same shape as the Navajo finding (same parts, same kind of dependence) and the counter-cases found limit it without removing it. WEAK = a resemblance in one respect, or an analog only at the level of description or notation, or a shape that the counter-cases break in an instructive way. NONE = nothing opened matches. A STRONG grade is not a correlate: the mechanisms (electrons and strain in a crystal; pronouns and prefixes in a verb) are not the same kind of thing.

What is new (one sentence). The closest sourced analog to "a slot with its own parameters, filled by whatever matches its features" is the geochemists' lattice-strain model, where a crystal site is described by three numbers (ideal radius, stiffness, maximum partition value) and an ion is scored only by its radius and charge against them — and the same source reports that the tempting context-free ranking (the smaller ion goes in first) fails, because "of critical importance is the size of the ions relative to the site of interest", which is the shape of the Navajo finding that the inverse ranks by capacity as the verb construes it; by contrast the "layered" conjecture has only a description-level analog (Wyckoff-position prototypes with the species written in last), and the one statistical test of the nearest site-first rule set (Pauling's) finds that only 13 % of oxides obey rules 2–5 together.


On this page

0. The four Navajo findings carried over

As stated on Navajo Decoded (feature bundles, eight ranks, who acts on whom, event structure, Hale derivation, theta-args thesis), with the survivors only; withdrawn rules (INV-CAP) and the strong thesis ("nouns are never arguments") are not carried.

  • (a) Role-bearing slots. The verb's argument is a bundle of person, number, capacity rank and role, spelled out as a prefix; a noun carries person, number and rank but no role, and links to the slot whose features it matches; position and topicality choose among matches (FB-1, FB-3). Status there: HYPOTHESIS, built on sourced pieces; conditional and undecided against configurational accounts after the Hale derivation.
  • (b) Ranking. Voice (yi- / bi-) is set by comparing the two participants' general capacity to act, then topicality for ties; among equals either voice; among two plants/objects the one the verb says moves outranks the stationary one (Creamer 1974; Witherspoon 1977). The capacity is read as the participant is construed (newborn, personified noun), with two verb-sensitive spots (lightning with ‘strike’; the mover).
  • (c) Layered assignment. Roles always apply; event-structure roles are a further layer; lexical-item choice comes last. Grant's conjecture, with published late-insertion precedents (Distributed Morphology, Borer) and, on the site, a family of three derivations the data cannot yet separate.
  • (d) Viewpoint and causation are in the word; telicity is not. Mode/aspect and the ł- vs y- causation-or-change prefixes sit in the verb; telic readings come from outside it (Smith, Perkins & Fernald 2007, as the site reports).

Verbatim statements of these from the Navajo pages are in navajo-site-quotes.txt (same folder as the excerpts file named in §1).


1. Sources opened this run

Source How read Used for
Blundy & Wood 2003, "Partitioning of trace elements between crystals and melts," Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 210: 383–397 Open copy; text layer (ligature glyphs repaired) Lattice-strain model; Goldschmidt's rules and which fail; charge-compensating defects; site size varies with composition
Shimizu, Liang, Sun, Jackson & Saal 2017, Am. Mineral. 102: 2254–2267 Open copy; text layer Amphibole M4 vs M1–M3 site types; (D₀, r₀, E) per site; parameters depend on P, T, composition
Föll, "Kröger–Vink notation" (Univ. Kiel, Advanced Materials A, §2.4.2) Web page Site × species grid; vacancyPoint defect: a missing atom site in the lattice. as a filler; charge relative to the lattice; constraints that link the entries
Goodall, Parackal, Faber, Armiento & Lee 2022, Sci. Adv. 8: eabn4117 (arXiv:2106.11132) arXiv PDF; text layer Wyckoff-position representation (space group + positions + the elements that sit on them); prototype-based substitution
Eckert et al. 2024, "AFLOW Library of Crystallographic Prototypes: Part 4" (arXiv:2401.06875v2) arXiv PDF; text layer Prototype label by space group and Wyckoff positions, independent of the compound; α-Ga and molecular iodine share one label
Glawe, Sanna, Gross & Marques 2016, New J. Phys. 18: 093011 Open access PDF; text layer Prototype = space group + occupied Wyckoff positions, species discarded; Pettifor scale as an empirical one-dimensional element ordering
George, Waroquiers, Di Stefano, Petretto, Rignanese & Hautier 2020, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 59: 7569 PMC full text (web) Statistical test of Pauling's five rules on about 5000 oxides
Batsanov et al. 2022, "Energy Electronegativity and Chemical Bonding," Molecules Europe PMC full-text XML Electronegativity depends on the valenceBonding capacity / oxidation-related electron count of an atom in context. state chosen
Kobayashi & Kawashima 2010, C. R. Chimie 13: 1249; Wang, Zhang, Glaser, Streitwieser & Schleyer 1993, J. Comput. Chem. 14: 522 Corpus copies from the apicophilicity note Apicophilicity rule and where it breaks

Verbatim passages relied on: lit/_pdfs/navajo-to-materials-connections/excerpts-verbatim.md (cut programmatically by make_excerpts.py from the text layers; sources S3 and S7 in kroger-vink-foell.txt and george2020.txt). Quote fragments in this note were machine-checked against those files. From earlier runs, reused from the corpus with their own excerpt files: TBP apicophilicity ranking edge, Spinel inversion ranking edge, Si donors: slot or element?, Dopant produce vs maintain.

Search extracts only (not opened; labelled where used): Ruban & Skriver, Phys. Rev. B 55: 856 (γ′-Ni₃Al site substitution); the Acta Materialia 54: 1147 abstract on the Idaho National Laboratory page (Ni₃Al site preference of Pt, Hf, Cr, Ir); Phys. Rev. B 85: 144117 introduction snippet (B2 NiAl). Their text is in extracts-only.md.

Not opened (do not treat as read): Blundy & Wood 1994 (Nature 372: 452, the original lattice-strain paper); Brice 1975; Onuma et al. 1968; Goldschmidt's own papers; Pauling 1929 (George et al. quote it); Pettifor 1984/1985 themselves (Glawe et al. describe them); the Wren code or its supplement; Hautier et al. 2011 on data-mined substitutions (Goodall et al. cite it); any metal-hostMajority element/phase whose lattice dominates the material. lattice-strain or soluteIntentional minority species dissolved in the host (alloying addition).-misfit source (Fleischer, Labusch, Varvenne–Curtin); Distributed Morphology and Borer sources (the Navajo site cites them; not re-read here).


2. Connection A — a slot with parameters of its own, filled by feature match

The Navajo finding. The role slot is complete before any noun arrives; a noun links to it by matching features; the noun's lexical identity matters only through those features (FB-1, FB-3).

2.1 Lattice strain: the site has three numbers, the ion is scored by two — STRONG

  • Sourced. Blundy & Wood: "Recognising that trace element ions enter specific lattice sites in minerals, Goldschmidt proposed that the key variables controlling partitioning are the charge and size of the trace ion relative to the charge and size of the lattice site, which itself varies with mineral composition. There is an energy penalty for size and charge mismatch that is reflected in lower partition coefficients for ions that do not fit well onto lattice sites compared to ions that do."
  • The model. "The elastic strain energy is roughly symmetrical about an optimum ionic size." The partition coefficient for a given site and charge "should vary near-parabolically with ionic radius." Shimizu et al. name the three parameters: "D₀ is the amphibole-melt partition coefficient for the strain-free substitution; r₀ is the radius of a hypothetical cation that substitutes into the site with zero strain; rⱼ is the ionic radius of the element of interest; E is the effective Young's modulus for the lattice site". So the slot carries (D₀, r₀, E); the filler enters only through its radius rⱼ and (by choosing which charge series applies) its charge.
  • Several slot types, one structure. Shimizu et al. on amphibole: "The smaller M1–M3 sites are in sixfold coordination, while the larger M4 site is in eightfold coordination. The latter can accommodate larger cations such as the trivalent rare earth elements (REE) and Y [ionic radii 0.977–1.16 Å, eightfold coordination, Shannon (1976)]". Two slot types in one crystal, each with its own parameters, each taking the ions whose features match.
  • Why STRONG (as an analog). Same parts: a typed slot with its own parameters; a filler reduced to a few features; the outcome set by the match. And a quantitative model, fitted to data, built on that division.
  • Counter-cases found, from the same sources. 1. The slot's numbers are not fixed by the slot type alone: "The lattice strain parameters (D₀, r₀, E) are, in general, a function of pressure (P), temperature (T), and composition (X)," and Blundy & Wood: "Changes in composition along a solid solutionSolute atoms dissolved into the host lattice (substitutional or interstitial) without a separate precipitate phase. series lead to small changes in the dimensions of a lattice site." The slot is partly set by what else fills the crystal. (Navajo side: the role (ρ) is fixed by the verb's schema, FB-2; there is no sourced Navajo analog of a slot whose shape shifts with its neighbours, and none claimed.) 2. The filler can create a second slot requirement: Heterovalent substitution (a different charge from the ion normally resident) "requires the presence of a chargecompensating defect (cation or anion) elsewhere in the lattice (e.g. Ln3+ +Na1+ = 2Ca2+ ), which will also entail some degree of lattice strain" (hyphen lost in the text layer). One ion in one slot drags a second slot into the event. 3. Same species, different slot depending on conditions (search extract, not opened): in Ni₃Al, "Pt always prefers Ni sites, while Cr and Hf always prefer Al sites," but "The site preference of Ir was found to be strongly composition-dependent … Ir is also strongly affected by temperature." And for B2 NiAl, "the results seem to be controversial" (extract).
  • What it does not show. That a slot is chosen before a filler is considered (the lattice-strain model scores a given ion against a given site; it does not say which comes first). That the process of doping selects slots (the Si-donor note makes the same limit explicit).

2.2 Kröger–Vink notation: an empty slot is still a slot — WEAK (notation, not mechanism)

  • Sourced. Föll: "We define vacancies and interstitials as particles which occupy a defined site in a crystal and which may have a charge." Sites "are the points where the atoms, the interstitials, or the vacancies can be." The notation records charge only "relative to the neutral lattice," which "defines the charge relative to the neutral lattice." And "A perfect crystal in the Kröger-Vink notation thus is full of vacancies on interstitial sites!"
  • Shape. A site × species grid in which the site is a first-class object, can be filled by "nothing" (a vacancy is written as a filler), and the filler's charge is stated relative to the slot's default occupant. That is the same bookkeeping move as a slot that exists with no overt noun (null argument; a ∅ third-person prefix). It is a way of writing, so WEAK.
  • Counter-case, same source. The entries are not independent: "There is no way within the system to produce a vacancy, e.g. V A without removing an A-particle, e.g. generating an A i or adding another B-particle, B B." And the "independence condition" for a mass-action law "is automatically not fulfilled if we have additional constraints which link some of our particles." Slots and fillers are tied by conservation, so the grid cannot be filled cell by cell.

2.3 Carried from earlier notes: Si donors — STRONG for the result side only (already graded in Si donors: slot or element?)

Effective-mass theory makes a shallow donor's binding depend only on the host, which holds in GaAs; in silicon the excited 1s states of P, As, Sb and Bi stay within about 2 meV of the slot-only value, while the ground state spreads over 28 meV because "atomic species differ from each other at the core region" (Saraiva et al. 2014, as quoted there). A slot template plus a filler-local correction whose size the host decides. Not reopened here.

Grade for (a): STRONG (2.1), with 2.2 WEAK beside it. Falsifier to look for: a source showing the site-type parameters (r₀, E) are not shared across fillers within one charge series.


3. Connection B — ranking fillers

The Navajo finding. Voice compares two participants by general capacity to act; ties go to topicality; for two objects the verb's moving one wins; capacity is read as the participant is construed, with two verb-sensitive spots.

3.1 A context-free rank fails; the working rank is relative to the slot — STRONG (as a shared pattern)

  • Sourced (materials). Goldschmidt's second rule is a context-free ranking: "when two ions have similar radii and the same charge, it is always the smaller ion that is more readily incorporated." Blundy & Wood give two examples. In clinopyroxene the larger Th⁴⁺ (1.05 Å) is described as more readily incorporated than U⁴⁺ (1.00 Å) where the M2 site is Ca-sized, but "diopside-poor clinopyroxenes, characteristic of the mantle solidus, have a smaller M2-site, which preferentially incorporates U rather than Th" (the first half of that sentence is interleaved with figure labels in the text layer, so it is paraphrased, not quoted). In garnet, "the larger Zr4+ ion can enter both the X- and Y-sites in some garnets, whereas smaller Hf4+ is largely confined to the Y-site in all garnets." So the same pair of ions swaps order when the site changes size. Then: "It is worth noting that both of these examples invalidate Goldschmidt's second 'rule', namely that when two ions have similar radii and the same charge, it is always the smaller ion that is more readily incorporated. Of critical importance is the size of the ions relative to the site of interest: no simple generalisation is possible." Their own remark on the first rule: "Goldschmidt's 'rules' have since proven to be an oversimplification (see below)."
  • Sourced (Navajo, as the Navajo site quotes Creamer). The ranking is "summed up in an inherent ‘capacity to act upon’ in relation to other beings", and "the nature of the verb plays a secondary role" (p. 29), yet "the semantic content of the verb implies movement on the part of one of the nouns in the sentence, and this noun then takes higher status than the more stationary object" (p. 36), and lightning ranks with persons only "when used with a verb denoting its characteristically potent striking force" (p. 33).
  • The shape in common. In both fields the first-guess ranking is a property of the filler alone (smaller ion first; a noun's rank group), the first guess mostly works, and the cases where it fails are repaired by making the rank relative to the other half of the pair: the site's size in the crystal, the verb's event in Navajo. In both, an intrinsic scale is the default, not the whole story.
  • Where they differ. Navajo's comparison is between two fillers (subject vs object). Lattice strain scores one ion against one site; the two-ion competition is left to the partition coefficients. The nearest chemistry to a two-filler comparison is competition between ions for a site (Goldschmidt's rules; the spinel and apicophilicity notes). So the parallel is about the failure pattern, not the machinery.
  • Counter-case. Creamer says the verb is "secondary": the intrinsic part dominates in her data. Blundy & Wood do not say the site-relative part is secondary; for them it is decisive ("no simple generalisation is possible"). The two fields weight the relative part differently.

3.2 Apicophilicity: a rank of groups by what they are, used to choose slots — STRONG within one molecular class (carried; see TBP apicophilicity ranking edge)

  • Sourced. In five-coordinate phosphorus, "In the trigonal bipyramidal structure, electronegative and small substituents prefer the apical positions. Such properties are widely recognized as the apicophilicity rule." A group is ranked by electronegativity, size and π-donation, not by whether it is entering or leaving (earlier note).
  • Counter-cases. The same abstract: "However, several examples breaking the apicophilicity rule have been reported in the past few decades". Wang et al. (computed): "Thus, apicophilicities cannot be rigorously defined for these substituents" (the highly electropositive ones Li, Na, BeH, MgH). The rank does not apply to every filler.
  • Fit to Navajo. The closest chemistry has to "a second ranking scale independent of the roles" (spec point 2 in that note). It passed there with the same caveat (scale breaks down for some fillers).

3.3 The rank depends on how the participant is construed — WEAK

  • Sourced. Batsanov et al.: "Unfortunately, there is serious ambiguity in specifying the valence state of some atoms; e.g., for N and O one has to choose from 7 and 8 possible states, respectively, with ionization energies and electron affinities covering ranges of 10 or more eV". And on bond energies: "it is really valid for low-polarity molecules only, for the bond energy depends on many factors besides the polarity, particularly on the bond distance, atomic valences and hybridization states."
  • Shape. An electronegativity value belongs to an atom as taken in a given valence state, as Navajo capacity belongs to a participant as construed (newborn vs capable child, personified tree). The resemblance is real in one respect and loose in every other (a valence state is a physical choice; a construal is a speaker's), so WEAK.

3.4 A rank induced from usage beats a rank derived from a principle — WEAK (method parallel)

  • Sourced (materials). Glawe et al., on Pettifor's structure maps: "There had been several previous attempts to achieve such separation using properties like the core radius, the electronegativity, the number of valence electrons, etc." … "but also to a rather disappointing structural separation. Pettifor's solution was rather elegant, but also quite radical. He neglected all theoretical considerations and constructed a fully phenomenological one-dimensional ordering of the elements that provided a near-perfect structural separation of the AB binaries." Glawe et al. rebuild the ordering from which elements substitute for each other in the same structure prototype: "Our working hypothesis is that the chemical elements A and B are similar if when mixed with other elements of the periodic table they crystallize in the same structure prototype."
  • Sourced (Navajo, as quoted on the site). Creamer: "The actual rankings … have not been derived from this common sense rationale, but from the review of a large number of typical Navajo sentences … The rationale was derived by inference out of usage, rather than the other way around."
  • Shape. Both rankings were obtained by sorting items by how they behave in slots and only afterwards given a rationale. A method parallel, not a mechanism; Pettifor's scale ranks similarity of elements, not who outranks whom in an event. WEAK.

3.5 Tie-break by speaker interest, and the moving-object rule — NONE

No opened source has an analog of "among equals the speaker's interest decides" (Creamer p. 32). Goldschmidt's first rule, "ions of the same charge and radius will enter a crystal lattice with equal ease," is the same result for ties (no preference), but it follows trivially from symmetry and has no topic factor, so it is not counted. The verb-says-it-moves rule (Creamer p. 36) has no opened chemistry analog; mobile dopantIntentional dilute impurity meant to tune electronic/optical/catalytic behavior without replacing the host as majority phase. versus host is the obvious place to look and was not opened. Not claimed.

Grade for (b): STRONG as a shared failure pattern for intrinsic ranks (3.1) and for the apicophilicity scale within its class (3.2); WEAK for construal and method; NONE for the tie-break and the mover rule.


4. Connection C — layered assignment (roles → event-structure roles → lexical item last)

The Navajo finding. Grant's conjecture; published precedents; three derivations the Navajo data cannot yet separate.

4.1 Prototype first, species last — STRONG as a description, WEAK as a mechanism (graded WEAK overall)

  • Sourced (description). Glawe et al.: "definition of a structure prototype. Each such prototype is defined by a space group and by the set of occupied Wyckoff positions. All other information concerning, e.g., the lattice constants or the chemical elements occupying the Wyckoff positions, is discarded." Eckert et al.: the AFLOW label describes "stoichiometry, unit cell Pearson symbol and space group, and occupied Wyckoff positions for each atomic species", "is independent of the choice of prototype compound", and "NaCl — halite — and hundreds of binary compounds [8, 9] all have the same prototype label, AB_cF8_225_a_b." Goodall et al.: a material is described by "a set of Wyckoff positions with the elements that sit on them", and in the substitution step "we count which element substitutions (including self substitutions) would be needed to change one structure into the other." So crystal chemistry has a standard object that is the site frame with the species left to be filled in, and a standard operation that fills it later. That is the shape of "roles first, lexical items last".
  • Counter-cases. 1. The frame does not fix the physics. Eckert et al.: α-Ga and molecular iodine "are in the same space group with a single (8f) occupied Wyckoff position, so they have the same AFLOW-prototype label, A_oC8_64_f." A metal and a molecular solid share one label. And "two structures with different atomic arrangements might have the same prototype label." 2. Filling the frame later is physically unreliable without a repair step. Goodall et al.: "In prototype-based substitution workflows … the distributions of bond distances seen before relaxation can be highly unphysical as the original species often have very different atomic radii to the substituted species," and relaxation changes "the unit cell volume." The species changes the frame. 3. Most structures are not substitution relatives. Glawe et al.: substitution partners "were detected in 20500 materials, corresponding to 44% of the usable set". 4. Species can create slots (the heterovalent case in 2.1): the order runs the other way, from filler to a second slot.
  • Why WEAK overall. The sourced layering is a layering of descriptions and search workflows. Nothing opened says a crystal "decides" the frame before the species in any physical order; the Wyckoff paper's model takes both together ("each Wyckoff position is simply labelled by a Wyckoff letter and the element"). If Grant's conjecture is read as a claim about how a verb's argument structure is described, the analog is strong; if read as a claim about the order of derivation, nothing opened supports a chemistry counterpart.

4.2 Site-first rules (Pauling) — WEAK, mostly as a counter-case

  • Sourced. Pauling's first rule: "[…] The coordination number of the cation [is determined] by the radius ratio [of cation and anion]." George et al. test it and the other four on about 5000 oxides: "Only 66 % of the tested local environments agreed with the expectation from Pauling's first rule." They give the reason: "We link the failure of the first rule to an inadequate fundamental assumption that a given cation should always be found in one and only one type of local environment." Combined: "Overall, only 13 % of all tested structures fulfil the second to fifth rules simultaneously." And a caution that bears directly on rank-by-size: "we do not believe that any simple rule directly linking ionic radius to local environment will ever be predictive in view of the local-environment diversity of many cations."
  • Shape. A rule set that picks the slot type from a filler feature (radius ratio) and then constrains how slots connect is a layered selection in outline. Counted against it: the statistics. One species is found in several slot types (β-Ga₂O₃ with Ga in "fourfold and sixfold coordination within the same compound"), so species does not map to a slot type, and slot type does not map to species.

4.3 The middle layer (event-structure roles) — NONE

Nothing opened has a layer between "site type" and "species" that corresponds to event-structure roles (causation, change of state, boundedness). The corpus's produce-vs-maintain notes are about processes, not about a layer in a site-assignment hierarchy; see §5.

Grade for (c): WEAK. Description-level analog only; counter-cases from every side; the middle layer has none.


5. Connection D — viewpoint and causation in the word; telicity outside

The Navajo finding. The verb carries a viewpoint (bounded or not) and causation or change of state (ł- vs y-); a telic reading comes from words outside the verb.

5.1 Producing vs holding a state, marked by form and stage, not by element — WEAK (carried; Dopant produce vs maintain)

The metals literature separates making a fine-grain structure from holding one "by stage and physical form, not by element" (the earlier note's finding): scandium produces as primary Al₃Sc nuclei in casting and holds as Al₃Sc dispersoids later. That is the same kind of division as one Navajo stem in several event shapes (change by the subject; change by a causer; a state held by a causer). The match is on causation and maintenance, which is the second half of (d); it says nothing about viewpoint (bounded vs unbounded). WEAK, because the Navajo marker sits on one stem and the metallurgical division sits on different physical objects.

5.2 A held state is a balance, not a completion — WEAK

Manohar, Ferry & Chandra (as quoted in Dopant produce vs maintain, §2.3): "the Zener limit is simply the critical grain radius which neither grows nor shrinks due to the balance of driving and pinning pressures. The equation gives no information about the actual process of grain growth." A limit state that the process description does not itself encode, set by two pressures. Beside the Navajo perfective ("bounded, not completed") this is a mood-level resemblance only: an unbounded process (growth) and a bounded outcome fixed by factors outside the process word. Nothing opened treats this as a feature of how a doping operation is described.

5.3 Telicity absent from the word, supplied from outside — NONE

The nearest candidate is the host's solubility limit setting where a doping process ends (corpus note on solubility windows, not reopened). That is true but uninformative: any finite process has an endpoint set by something. No source opened presents "the operation does not encode its endpoint" as a modelling choice, so no analog is claimed.

Grade for (d): WEAK for causation (5.1) and held states (5.2); NONE for telicity and for viewpoint as such.


6. Scorecard

# Navajo finding (survivor) Best sourced materials analog Grade Main counter-case
A Role slot with own parameters; filler matched by features Lattice-strain model: site (D₀, r₀, E), ion scored by radius and charge; M4 vs M1–M3 in amphibole STRONG Slot parameters depend on P, T, composition; heterovalent filler needs a second (compensating) slot; Ni₃Al site preference moves with composition and temperature (extract)
A′ Slot exists unfilled Kröger–Vink: vacancy as a filler; charge relative to the lattice WEAK Entries are tied by conservation; not independent
A″ Slot template + filler-local correction Si donors (earlier note) STRONG (result side) Process side not opened
B Rank by capacity, relative to the pair Goldschmidt's context-free "smaller first" fails; rank relative to the site STRONG (failure pattern) Navajo compares fillers, lattice strain scores one ion vs one site; Creamer calls the verb part "secondary"
B′ Second scale independent of roles Apicophilicity (TBP phosphorus) STRONG (one class) Rule broken; "cannot be rigorously defined" for some groups
B″ Rank as construed Electronegativity depends on valence state WEAK Valence state is physical; construal is a speaker's
B‴ Rank induced from usage Pettifor / Glawe WEAK Ranks similarity, not who outranks whom
B⁗ Tie → speaker interest; mover outranks stationary none NONE —
C Roles → event roles → lexical item last Wyckoff prototypes with species written in last; AFLOW labels; substitution into prototypes WEAK Same label, unlike physics (α-Ga, I₂); substitution needs relaxation; 44 % of materials have substitution partners; Pauling rules obeyed by 13 %
C′ Middle layer: event-structure roles none NONE —
D Causation / maintenance in the word Produce vs hold by stage and form (earlier note) WEAK Different physical objects, not one stem
D′ Viewpoint (bounded) in the word Zener limit as a balance, not a completion WEAK Mood-level only
D″ Telicity not in the word none NONE —

7. Navajo findings with no chemistry analog (nothing opened)

  1. The tie-break by the speaker's interest (topic) among equal ranks, and the verb-says-it-moves rule between two objects.
  2. Linking a noun to a slot by agreement in person and number plus position (FB-3): the chemical filler has no separate "noun" form that has to be attached to the slot; the ion either sits there or does not.
  3. The Condition C / binding results (Hale 1999 and the derivation) and the fourth-person escape from the ranking scale (the earlier fourth-person note found no chemical correlate either).
  4. The event-structure middle layer and the telicity point (above).
  5. The yi- / bi- alternation as morphology: voice as a choice between two surface forms of one relation. Chemistry has no sourced analog of one relation with two ranked-dependent spell-outs.

8. What looks most promising, and what to do next

  1. Lattice strain as the best-formed analog of a typed slot (A). Next: open Blundy & Wood 1994 and Brice 1975 for how the parabola is derived, then look for a metal-host version. The Si-donor note's open question 3 asked for a metal property with the same split (long-range set by the slot, short-range by the element). Solute strengthening is the candidate: it is classically written in terms of a size misfit and a modulus misfit, the same kind of pair as the lattice-strain model's (r₀, E). That similarity is my inference, not a sourced statement; it needs a solute-strengthening source (Fleischer, Labusch, Varvenne–Curtin) opened before any claim. → Checked 2026-10-15 evening in Solute strengthening: host part vs element part: the host/solute split is real and sourced (STRONG), but this pairing was mis-mapped — r₀ and E are both site parameters, while size and modulus misfit are both solute-in-host parameters. Corrected: host stiffness ↔ E, host reference size ↔ r₀, size misfit ↔ rⱼ − r₀ (STRONG for the elastic form); the modulus misfit has no lattice-strain partner. The pairing as written here is graded WEAK.
  2. The failure pattern of context-free ranks (B). Next: open sources on Zr–Hf and Nb–Ta fractionation (Blundy & Wood's own examples) and on Ni₃Al / NiAl site preference (Ruban & Skriver full text) to see whether site-relative rules (electronic structure, not size) are stated as a replacement for the intrinsic rank. If so, the chemistry parallel to "rank depends on verb and construal" gets sharper.
  3. Apicophilicity (B′) and spinel site preference already carry the clearest second-scale-independent-of-role cases; the Navajo ranking page can now be set beside them with the Creamer data in hand.
  4. Do not pursue C as a mechanism until a source states a site-then-species order of decision rather than of description. One test: an in-situ study of a growing crystal that finds the site frame forms before species are chosen (nothing like this is known to this note).
  5. For the Navajo side (Grant's call): the lattice-strain result suggests asking whether Navajo's rank is, like the geochemists', really relative to the slot (the verb's event) with an intrinsic default. Creamer's own lightning and mover exceptions point that way; the Navajo site could test it with verb-by-verb data.

9. Separation

SOURCED (inside each field)

Lattice-strain model, its parameters and its Goldschmidt corrections (Blundy & Wood; Shimizu et al.); Kröger–Vink notation (Föll); Wyckoff representations and AFLOW labels (Goodall et al.; Eckert et al.; Glawe et al.); Pauling-rule statistics (George et al.); electronegativity and valence state (Batsanov et al.); apicophilicity (Kobayashi & Kawashima; Wang et al.); the Navajo statements as stated on Navajo Decoded.

ANALYSIS (mine, beside the sources)

The grades; the failure-pattern comparison in §3.1; the description-vs-mechanism split in §4.1; the possible link from lattice-strain parameters to solute-strengthening misfits (flagged as inference).

HIS (Grant's) — SPECULATIVE

Layered assignment (c) is Grant's conjecture; the Navajo site marks it as such. The phrase-to-molecule and verb-to-operation frames remain his.

Not claimed

No chemical correlate is declared. No chemical stand-in for a theta role, a feature bundle or a rank. Not a joint field. Bridge A unrevised. No claim that a crystal site selects its filler in time order. No claim about the process side of doping (site choice by a process), which was not opened.


10. Verdict

Of the four surviving Navajo findings, (a) a slot with parameters of its own filled by feature match and (b) a ranking that is a default rather than the whole story have STRONG sourced analogs, in the lattice-strain model and in Goldschmidt's invalidated "smaller ion first" rule. (c) layered assignment has only a description-level analog (Wyckoff-position prototypes with species written in last), and every opened counter-case cuts at it. (d) survives as a causation-and-maintenance shape and as a held-state shape, WEAK, and has no analog for telicity or viewpoint proper. The tie-break, the moving-object rule, the event-structure layer and telicity have no analog in anything opened.


v0 — 2026-10-15 PT. Pointers added: corpus-reading-order row, CONCLUSIONS-v1-addendum paragraph, site-content-map. Speculation flagged. Bridge A lock unrevised. No joint field.

Corpus note: navajo-to-materials-connections-v0.md. The materials and crystal chemistry are same-domain description; the Navajo statements are quoted as Navajo Decoded states them. Each grade is a grade of a sourced analog, not a declared correlate. No chemical stand-in for a theta role. Layered assignment is Grant’s conjecture and is speculative. Not Bridge A. Not a joint field.